Deavo
LegalExpert answer · 2 min read

Can a court rewrite an overly broad non-compete from a business sale?

In Martin v. ConCreate (2013 ONCA 72) the Court of Appeal for Ontario held sale-related non-compete and non-solicit covenants unreasonable and agreed they could not be saved by blue-pencil or notional severance. Do not count on a court fixing the clause for you.

This page covers Ontario; check the rules where you are. A seller who signs a broad non-compete may hope a court would simply trim it to something reasonable. In Martin v. ConCreate, the Court of Appeal for Ontario did not do that. The application judge had found the non-compete and non-solicit clauses reasonable and enforceable. The Court of Appeal reversed that, declaring them unenforceable, and agreed with the application judge that they could not be saved by “blue pencil” or “notional” severance. The result turned on that covenant’s facts.

What went wrong in Martin

Derek Martin signed the covenants in conjunction with the sale of two businesses. They ended a set period after he disposed of the indirect interest he acquired in the sale, and he could not dispose of it without the approval of the general partner’s board and any required lender approvals. The court held the duration unreasonable because it depended on third-party consents, was indeterminate and had no fixed, outside limit. It did not find the clauses ambiguous. The confidentiality clause stayed enforceable.

Why the court would not repair it

The application judge said that if these covenants were unreasonable in scope, territory or duration, saving them by either kind of severance would entail rewriting the contract for the parties. Martin’s agreements did contain a clause saying a court could reduce an unreasonable duration or area; the covenants were still held unenforceable. The respondents did not contest that and did not appeal it, so the Court of Appeal did not analyse the point afresh but agreed with his conclusion. The court also said that Martin’s agreement in a sale, his lawyer and his acknowledgement of reasonableness were important factors but did not entirely immunize the clause from scrutiny.

Ambiguity is a separate problem

Martin, citing the Supreme Court’s Shafron decision, says that if a covenant is unclear as to activity, time or geography, it is not possible to show it is reasonable. In Mason v. Chem-Trend, an employee case, the court describes Shafron as involving “Metropolitan City of Vancouver”, which had no legal or judicial definition, an ambiguity that could not be read down or rectified.

What to check in your own clause

  • Does the end date depend on anyone else’s consent or on a future event you do not control? Martin’s did.
  • Is every place, activity and time period defined in words a court could apply?
  • Does the non-solicit reach only customers of the business sold? Martin’s also reached later customers, which the court found unreasonable, though that point was not decisive.
  • Is each restriction in its own clause? In Martin the confidentiality clause survived while the others fell.

Ask your lawyer to read the words with this in mind. See are non-competes enforceable in Canada, radius restrictions after a sale and severability. Under Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 s.67.2(3), if the buyer and seller agree to a non-compete as part of the sale and the seller becomes the buyer’s employee immediately after it, the Act’s non-compete ban (s.67.2(1)) does not apply to that agreement.

Sources

This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.

  1. 01
    Court of Appeal for OntarioCourt decision
    Martin v. ConCreate USL Limited Partnership, 2013 ONCA 72
    ontariocourts.ca·Checked Nov 4, 2026
  2. 02
    Court of Appeal for OntarioCourt decision
    Mason v. Chem-Trend Limited Partnership, 2011 ONCA 344
    ontariocourts.ca·Checked Nov 4, 2026
  3. 03
    Government of OntarioGovernment
    Employment Standards Act, 2000, S.O. 2000, c. 41
    ontario.ca·Checked Oct 20, 2026

Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.