Can a seller’s non-compete cover places the business never operated?
In MEDIchair, Ontario’s Court of Appeal quoted the Supreme Court’s statement that a clause applying outside the territory where the business operates is contrary to public order. In Martin, it agreed that a Canada-wide territory was reasonable for a business the parties expected to be national. Each result turned on its facts.
In MEDIchair, the Court of Appeal, quoting an earlier Ontario decision, said a party’s entitlement to enforce a restrictive covenant is based on protecting a legitimate or proprietary interest, such as the goodwill of a business that has been purchased. The territory in the clause is tested against that interest. This page covers Ontario decisions and Ontario’s statute. Check the rules where you are. It describes what two Court of Appeal for Ontario decisions held; it does not say whether any particular clause would be enforced.
What MEDIchair decided
In MEDIchair LP v. DME Medequip Inc., 2016 ONCA 168, a franchisor sought to enforce a restrictive covenant against a former franchisee. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and dismissed the application. The franchisor’s own witness agreed on cross-examination that, as long as a competing store owned within the same corporate group was in Peterborough, there was no plan to open a new MEDIchair store there. The Court held that, by deciding not to operate there, the franchisor had effectively acknowledged that it had no legitimate or proprietary interest to protect within the covenant’s territory. The Court said the clause was not struck down as generally unreasonable, and its territorial boundaries were not unreasonably broad; it was unreasonable as between those two parties because the franchisor had no legitimate or proprietary interest to protect within its territory. It was a franchise covenant, not a sale of a business.
Outside the territory where the business operates
The Court in MEDIchair quoted the Supreme Court’s decision in Payette v. Guay: a non-competition clause that applies outside the territory in which the business operates is contrary to public order. It also noted an earlier Ontario case, McAllister v. Cardinal, where the court refused to enforce a covenant covering a greater area than where the purchased business actually operated. The MEDIchair Court also set out, from Payette, that the test of reasonableness is whether the clause is limited, as to its term and to the territory and activities to which it applies, to whatever is necessary for the protection of the legitimate interests of the party in whose favour it was granted.
When a wide area was upheld
In Martin v. ConCreate USL Limited Partnership, 2013 ONCA 72, the covenants given on a sale covered Canada. The Court of Appeal saw no basis to interfere with the application judge’s finding that the parties envisaged that the scope of the business was and would be national, agreed that the geographical scope was reasonable, and said the information memorandum and slideshow shown to the buyers were relevant to the parties’ reasonable expectations. It still allowed Martin’s appeal and declared two of the covenants unenforceable, because of their duration rather than their territory. MEDIchair also recalled an earlier case, Tank Lining, where a Canada-wide covenant was challenged because the parties only had business in some provinces; the court held that the reasonable expectation when the agreement was made was that the business would expand across Canada, and the test of reasonableness applied to that expectation.
What to check in the clause
- Where the business actually had customers, and what records show it.
- How the clause defines the territory and how it is measured, for example by named places or from a stated point.
- Whether the sale materials describe the business as reaching further than it did.
- Whether the buyer, or a related business, actually operates in that area. See also whether a radius restriction stops you opening nearby.
Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 s.67.2(3) provides that the ban does not apply to a sale agreement’s non-compete if the seller becomes the purchaser’s employee immediately following the sale. It says nothing about territory. For the wider picture, see whether non-competes are enforceable in Canada.
Related reading
4 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Court of Appeal for OntarioCourt decisionMEDIchair LP v. DME Medequip Inc., 2016 ONCA 168
- 02Court of Appeal for OntarioCourt decisionMartin v. ConCreate USL Limited Partnership, 2013 ONCA 72
- 03Government of OntarioGovernmentEmployment Standards Act, 2000, S.O. 2000, c. 41
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.