Can I make key staff sign non-competes after closing?
In Ontario, generally not: the Employment Standards Act, 2000 now generally prohibits employers from entering non-compete agreements with employees, with two recognized exceptions. Ask an employment lawyer whether either applies to the person, and which rules apply in your province.
In Ontario, the Employment Standards Act, 2000 now generally prohibits employers from entering non-compete agreements with employees, with two recognized exceptions. In Ontario, the first is where the person signing is selling a business, or part of one, and becomes an employee of the purchaser as part of that sale. In Ontario, the second is where the person is an executive in a defined, C-suite-style role. If the person you want to bind fits neither, ask an employment lawyer before you put a non-compete in front of them.
Work out who you are asking to sign
- Is the person the seller, selling a business or part of one and staying on as the buyer’s employee after closing?
- Is the person an executive in a defined, C-suite-style role?
- Is the person an ordinary employee who fits neither description?
- Is the person actually an employee at all, or an independent contractor or partner? In Ontario, the ban applies to employees.
Ask your lawyer to put the answer for each person in writing before any document is drafted. In Ontario, the answer can change which rules apply.
Ask about the seller’s promise and an employee’s separately
In Ontario, courts have generally shown more willingness to enforce reasonable non-competes in the sale-of-business context than in the employment context. In Ontario, where a seller stays on as an employee after the sale, that continuing connection can be relevant to whether the non-compete falls within the Employment Standards Act, 2000’s narrow business-sale exception. In Ontario, even where the Act allows a non-compete, whether its terms hold up if challenged depends on how reasonable they are in scope. Ask your lawyer to check the seller’s covenant and any employee covenant separately.
Non-solicitation, confidentiality and retention
In Ontario, non-solicitation clauses are not affected by the Employment Standards Act, 2000’s non-compete ban in the same way as non-competes. Ask your lawyer whether a non-solicitation clause or a confidentiality obligation would meet your purpose for a particular person.
In Ontario, a key employee retention agreement is one of the main tools sellers, and sometimes buyers, use to keep critical people in place through the transition. In Ontario, it can include related obligations, but each type of clause serves a different function and has different enforceability rules. In Ontario, a non-compete, for instance, is generally void under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 unless a recognized exception applies. In Ontario, the incentive in a retention agreement is commonly a retention bonus, though its size and structure are entirely deal-specific.
Questions to put before anyone signs
- Ask the seller for each key employee’s existing employment agreement and any restrictive clause they already signed.
- Ask your lawyer whether a retention agreement conflicts with any new employment contract the buyer separately offers.
- Ask your lawyer who should pay a retention bonus, the buyer or the seller, and how that is written into the purchase agreement.
- Ask your lawyer whether any clause you plan to use is permitted for that person under the rules of the province where they work.
Related reading
12 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Legal
- DefinitionNon-compete (restrictive covenant)
- DefinitionNon-solicitation clause
- DefinitionKey employee retention agreement
- Expert answerAre non-compete agreements enforceable in Canada?
- ComparisonNon-compete vs non-solicit
- Expert answerWhat post-closing covenants like non-competes and transition support bind a seller?
- GuideNon-competes in an asset sale vs a share sale
Selling
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryAre Non-Compete Clauses Enforceable Against Regulated Professionals Selling a Practice in Ontario?
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Long Can a Seller's Non-Compete Last in an Ontario Business Sale?
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryKey Employee Retention Agreements
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.