Can you buy your way out of a non-compete after selling a business?
A seller’s non-compete is a promise made to the buyer, so a release or narrowing is something to agree with the buyer, or whoever holds its benefit under your agreement, and to put in writing. Whether any payment for that is taxed is a separate question under Income Tax Act s.56.4.
BDC describes a non-compete in a purchase agreement as a covenant where the vendor promises not to take part in a competing business for a period after closing. It is a promise made to someone, the buyer. So the question is less whether a seller can simply step out of it and more whether the buyer will agree to release it or narrow it. Nothing checked for this page says a buyer must agree, and what yours allows depends on the wording you signed.
Put any release or narrowing in writing
Treat a change as a document, not a conversation. Ask your lawyer to record any release, waiver or narrowing in writing, signed by whoever holds the benefit of the covenant. Read the agreement to see who that is: the buyer, the buyer’s company, or someone the benefit was assigned to along with the business. Ask, too, whether the promise appears in more than one place, such as the purchase agreement and a separate employment or consulting agreement, and whether each needs its own release. For the promises a seller gives at closing, see what post-closing covenants bind a seller.
What the Income Tax Act says about restrictive covenants
Section 56.4(1) defines a restrictive covenant of a taxpayer as “an agreement entered into, an undertaking made, or a waiver of an advantage or right by the taxpayer, whether legally enforceable or not”, that affects, or is intended to affect, in any way whatever, the acquisition or provision of property or services by the taxpayer or by another taxpayer who does not deal at arm’s length with the taxpayer. The definition lists agreements and undertakings it leaves out. Under s.56.4(2), amounts received or receivable in respect of a restrictive covenant of the taxpayer, by the taxpayer or by a taxpayer who does not deal at arm’s length with the taxpayer, are included in computing the taxpayer’s income, other than an amount already included because of that subsection in the taxpayer’s income for an earlier year, or in the taxpayer’s eligible corporation’s income for that year or an earlier year, and subject to the exceptions that follow in s.56.4. The Canada Revenue Agency’s page on the topic states that it “is under review”. How these words apply to a payment for a release, and which party is the taxpayer, is a question for your tax adviser. A related page covers whether a selling shareholder can be paid tax-free for a non-compete.
Questions to take to your advisers
- Does the covenant bind you personally, your company, or both?
- Who holds its benefit today, and was it assigned?
- Would a narrower covenant meet what each side needs, and how will the amendment be signed?
- Is anything being paid or given up for a release, and how will the document describe it?
Deavo does not say whether you should ask for a release or pay for one. That is a decision for you, with your lawyer and tax adviser.
Related reading
5 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Legal
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Government of Canada (Department of Justice)GovernmentIncome Tax Act, section 56.4 (restrictive covenants)
- 02Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentRestrictive covenant
- 03Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernmentMajor pitfalls to avoid when negotiating a purchase agreement
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.