Deavo
Due diligenceExpert answer · 1 min read

How do I check how an online trading card seller grades and sorts its singles?

Ask for the written grading standard, then test it. Pull a handful of cards at each grade and compare them with the standard and the live listings. Check who grades, how disputes about condition are handled, and how often grades change. A seller whose cards match the descriptions will have fewer returns.

Start with the standard. Ask what each grade means in plain words, what flaws move a card down, and whether photos of examples are kept for staff to compare. If the standard exists only in the owner’s head, note it as a risk, because the owner’s judgment may be hard to repeat. Keep the sample notes in one simple table. Add a line that notes who prepared it and the date.

Then run a sample. Pick cards from several grades and from different sets. Compare them against the standard, then against the listing text and photos. Do the same for a few cards that have already shipped, using returns and complaint totals with customer names removed. A pattern of returns in one grade is telling. Keep a short note of any grade changes made after a complaint. It shows a buyer that the standard is a living document and that mistakes lead to a clear adjustment, not an argument.

Next, look at the flow. Ask where new cards are graded, how they are sleeved and sorted, and what stops a card from landing in the wrong bin. Ask how many people grade, and whether they are checked against each other. Finally, ask your accountant how stock is valued in the books by grade, and how write-downs are decided.

Key takeaways

  • Ask for the written standard and photo examples of each grade.
  • Test a sample of cards against listings and the standard.
  • Look at return totals by grade, with customer names removed.

Sources

This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.

  1. 01
    Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernment
    How to conduct due diligence when buying a business
    bdc.ca·Checked Oct 21, 2026
  2. 02
    Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernment
    What is inventory
    bdc.ca·Checked Oct 24, 2026
  3. 03
    Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernment
    What are the steps to buying a business?
    bdc.ca·Checked Oct 21, 2026

Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.