How do I value a business with messy books?
An Ontario article on cleaning up the books before a sale advises testing whether the records reconcile: bank statements, accounting records and financial statements should agree with each other, ideally across multiple years. Where they do not, ask a qualified valuator or accountant what can and cannot be relied on before anyone puts a value on the business.
An Ontario article on cleaning up the books says inconsistent bookkeeping makes it harder for a buyer to trust the trend lines. An Ontario article on reading financial statements before buying says a seller’s own summary is a starting point, not a substitute for the underlying financial statements and tax filings. This page covers what to check and ask; the valuation itself belongs with a qualified professional.
Start by testing whether the records reconcile
An Ontario source on cleaning up financial statements before a sale advises reconciling the books so that bank statements, accounting records and financial statements agree with each other, ideally across multiple years. As a buyer, run the same test: do the deposits in the bank statements line up with the revenue in the financial statements, year by year? Where they do not, ask the seller to explain each difference in writing.
What to ask the seller for
- Bank statements for the same years as the financial statements, to compare deposits with reported revenue
- Filed tax returns for those years, and an explanation of any difference between them and the financial statements
- Credit card statements and invoices behind the largest expense categories where the ledger is incomplete
- A list of expenses that were personal or discretionary, with records showing what each one was and why it is not a cost of running the business going forward
- A plain statement of which years or categories cannot be supported by any record
Personal expenses and add-backs
The same source notes that personal expenses, such as a vehicle, travel or family members on payroll who do not work in the business, are sometimes recorded as business expenses in owner-operated businesses. Ask which expenses the seller says are personal, and ask for the documents that show it. An adjustment that has no record behind it is a claim to verify, not a figure to rely on.
Who should do the valuation
Ask a qualified accountant or business valuator to do it, and ask about their credentials and their experience with businesses of a similar size and industry. Ask that the report say which valuation approach was used, what adjustments were made to the financial statements, and what risks or uncertainties the valuator flagged, including any that come from the state of the records.
If the records stay incomplete
Verify the seller’s financial summary against source documents with your own accountant before relying on it in an offer. If gaps remain, ask your accountant and lawyer how they should be handled in the offer, for example through verification before you commit.
Related reading
6 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Valuation
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryCleaning Up Financial Statements Before Selling Your Ontario Business
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow to Read a Business's Financial Statements Before You Buy in Ontario
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.