Is a declining business ever worth buying?
Whether a declining business is worth buying depends on facts you can establish before any offer: what caused the decline, whether that cause can be addressed under new ownership, and what plan and financing you would have. Put those questions to the seller, an accountant and a lender; none of this judges any particular business.
Before you decide anything about a falling business, find out why it is falling, and ask what, if anything, a new owner could change about that cause.
Questions that separate a fixable decline from a structural one
- Ask the seller to say, in specific terms, what changed and when: less spending on marketing, equipment or staff, slipping service or hours, a lease dispute, a departed manager, or a shift in the wider market
- Ask for monthly figures, not only yearly totals, so you can see when the decline started and whether it is still going
- Ask what evidence separates a cause within the business from a cause in the market, such as customer counts, supplier invoices or competitor openings nearby
- Ask whether the cause would still be there after the ownership changes, or whether it came from how the current owner ran things
- Speak with the people who deal with the business, such as key staff, major suppliers and, if the seller allows it, long-standing customers
Price and structure when the trend is down
In Ontario, an asking price is only the price the seller has chosen to ask, and a valuation is a starting point rather than a final price. Compare the asking price with what an accountant or a qualified valuator makes of the actual trend, not only the stronger earlier years. Where you and the seller disagree about whether the decline will reverse, ask your lawyer whether part of the price could be tied to performance after closing, through a holdback or an earn-out, which Ontario guidance describes as a way to bridge a genuine disagreement about value.
Financing and the cash beyond the price
In Ontario, the headline price is rarely the whole picture once you add a deposit, closing costs and the working capital needed to run the business from day one. The same Ontario guidance says financing might come from a bank loan, a vendor take-back where the seller finances part of the price, personal capital, or some combination. Ask the lender how it would assess a declining trend and what it would need to see, and ask the seller whether a vendor take-back is open for discussion. Build the plan around what a lender confirms for this business, not around a comparable business with a steady record.
What to have before you commit
Write down a specific plan for what changes under your ownership and why that change addresses the cause of the decline. If you cannot state the cause in one sentence, you are not ready to say whether the fix is realistic. Have your accountant and lawyer review the figures, the plan and the deal terms before you sign anything.
Related reading
4 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Much Is a Small Business Worth? Valuation Basics for Ontario Buyers
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryA First-Time Business Buyer's Guide to Buying in Ontario
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.