Should I accept shares instead of cash for my business?
Whether to accept shares of the buyer’s company instead of cash is a decision to work through with your own lawyer and tax advisor. Ask what the shares are, whether and how you could sell them, how the exchange would be taxed, and what information you would receive about the company.
If an offer includes shares of the buyer’s company, ask the buyer to put in writing exactly what is being offered and how it would be paid. This page lists questions to take to your lawyer and your tax advisor. It does not say whether accepting shares suits any seller.
Questions about the shares themselves
- Which company issues the shares, and which class are they?
- What rights come with that class, such as voting, information or dividends, if any?
- Is there any agreement that lets you sell the shares, requires the buyer or the company to buy them back, or requires you to sell if a majority owner sells? Ask for the wording.
- What happens to your stake if the company brings in new investors or its majority owner sells?
Questions about the buyer’s business
BDC says an accountant helps a seller prepare year-end and interim financial statements, projections and other documents that buyers typically ask to see as part of due diligence. If you are being offered shares, ask the buyer for the same kinds of documents about its own company, and ask your accountant to review them with you. Ask also about its debt and who manages it.
Questions for your tax advisor
Ask your accountant how receiving shares rather than cash would be taxed, and whether any deferral or rollover applies to your exchange. Ask before you sign, so that the structure can still change. In Ontario, one law-firm article says the Lifetime Capital Gains Exemption lets an individual shelter some or all of a capital gain realized personally on a disposition of qualifying small business corporation shares, up to a lifetime limit. The same Ontario article says it applies only to shares, and only shares that meet the qualifying small business corporation tests. Ask your accountant whether your shares qualify and how a share exchange with this buyer would affect that.
Staying involved after the sale
BDC lists ways a seller can remain involved with a company after the sale: vendor financing, an earn-out, a phased transfer of ownership, or a role as an executive, board member or advisor. If the offer mixes cash and shares, ask whether any of these is also part of it, and have each term written down.
Related reading
13 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Valuation
Selling
- Expert answerWhen do I actually get paid when I sell my business?
- Expert answerCan I sell my business gradually instead of all at once?
- Expert answerShould I bring in a partner or investor instead of selling my business?
- ComparisonFull sale vs partial sale
- Expert answerWhat if the seller demands a share pledge instead of a promissory note?
- Expert answerCan a recapitalization work as a partial exit for a business owner?
- Expert answerWhy can’t I just sell my shares to my own holding company?
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Business Development Bank of CanadaIndustryHow to sell your business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow the Lifetime Capital Gains Exemption Shapes the Asset vs Share Decision in Ontario
- 03Canadian Federation of Independent BusinessResearch dataCapital Gains Changes
- 04Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.