What are the most common post-closing disputes?
In Ontario business sales, post-closing disputes can arise over breach of representations and warranties, working capital or price adjustments, undisclosed liabilities, earn-out calculations and breaches of non-compete or non-solicit promises.
After an Ontario business sale closes, disagreements between buyer and seller can arise over a short list of issues. Each one depends on what the purchase agreement says, so each is worth raising with your lawyer while the agreement is still a draft.
The working capital or price adjustment
A working capital or closing-statement adjustment arises when the actual level of receivables, inventory, payables or cash differs from what was estimated at closing. When the buyer’s and seller’s accountants land on different numbers, for example because of how inventory, receivables or accruals were counted, a dispute over the adjustment can follow. If the agreement provides for it, its dispute mechanism may refer the question to an independent accountant for a binding determination. Ask whether the clause names the accounting methodology, and agree it before closing rather than after the numbers come in.
Undisclosed liabilities
A liability that surfaces after closing can lead to a dispute. In an Ontario share sale, the company’s payables and other liabilities stay with the company the buyer now owns. In an asset sale, the buyer and seller identify which liabilities the buyer assumes and which stay with the seller, and the agreement’s wording controls. Whether the buyer has a claim for something undisclosed depends on whether the seller’s representations and warranties cover it. Ask about indemnities and about a holdback or escrow, which gives the buyer a pool of funds to draw against if an undisclosed liability turns up.
Breach of representations and warranties
The seller makes statements in the purchase agreement about the financial statements, contracts, employees, compliance and more. If one proves wrong, the buyer may claim under the indemnity. Those claims may be subject to a survival period set out in the agreement itself, so ask what the period is and which statements it covers. A thorough, specific disclosure schedule helps, because vague disclosure invites vague disputes.
Earn-outs and restrictive covenants
An earn-out dispute depends heavily on how the earn-out clause was drafted, so ask for objective, measurable criteria and clear rules on how the buyer must run the business during the earn-out period. A non-compete or non-solicitation dispute arises when the buyer believes the seller has started competing or poaching staff or customers. These can start with a demand letter.
Related reading
6 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Buying
- Expert answerWhat gets prorated on closing day?
- Expert answerCan a buyer be held liable for the seller’s unpaid tax?
- Expert answerHow do wire transfers and the funds flow work at a business sale closing?
- Expert answerCan I dispute the inventory figures after a business sale closes?
- Expert answerWhat share claims can a buyer not see on the corporate register?
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Treadstone LawLegal commentaryCommon Post-Closing Disputes in Business Sales
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryDisputing a Post-Closing Price Adjustment — Ontario
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryAccounts Payable at Closing — Ontario Business Sale
- 04Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.