Deavo
ValuationExpert answer · 2 min read

What are the signs a business is overpriced?

Ontario guidance points to warning signs worth testing: aggressive add-backs, earnings concentrated in one or two customers, relationships that depend on the owner personally, and reluctance to share several years of tax returns. No single sign proves a business is overpriced on its own. Have an accountant test each one.

None of these signs proves a price is wrong on its own. This page draws on Ontario guidance; check the rules where you are. Treat each sign as a prompt for a question or a document request.

Heavy reliance on aggressive add-backs

Each add-back adjusts the seller’s reported earnings, for example for the owner’s pay, personal expenses run through the business, or one-time costs. In Ontario, the guidance notes that some add-backs are legitimate but a large stack of them can mean reported profit is doing a lot of the selling, and that every claimed add-back should be verified against receipts, payroll records or other documentation, ideally by your own accountant. An unsupported add-back is an assertion, not a normalized number. Ask the seller for the document behind each line, and recalculate the earnings before you discuss price.

Check which earnings measure is in use

Ask whether the figure quoted is seller’s discretionary earnings (SDE) or EBITDA. In Ontario, SDE is described as meant to represent the total financial benefit to a single owner-operator, with the owner’s labour not treated as a separate cost, while EBITDA typically deducts a market-rate cost for management. Ask the seller or broker to state which measure the asking price rests on, and have your accountant confirm it was calculated consistently.

Customer concentration

Ontario guidance lists heavy customer concentration behind the revenue number as a financial red flag. Ask for a revenue breakdown by customer and check whether the largest customers have written contracts.

Value that depends on the owner

Key relationships that depend on the current owner personally, rather than on the business’s systems, brand or staff, may simply leave when the owner does. Ask what transition period the seller will commit to, and which customer, supplier and staff relationships run through the owner alone.

Records that are thin or curated

  • Reluctance to provide multiple years of tax returns, offering only a curated summary instead.
  • No clear paper trail for major contracts, especially with the largest customers or suppliers.
  • Financials your accountant cannot reconcile to the tax filings.

Test the price against financing

Ask your accountant to take the earnings you would actually have, subtract the cost of the work you will do, and compare what remains with the loan payments needed to buy at the asking price. Ask your lender how they would assess the same figures.

Sources

This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.

  1. 01
    Treadstone LawLegal commentary
    Signs a Business Is Overpriced in Ontario
    treadstonelaw.ca·Checked Aug 26, 2026
  2. 02
    Treadstone LawLegal commentary
    SDE and EBITDA Explained for Business Buyers — Ontario
    treadstonelaw.ca·Checked Aug 26, 2026
  3. 03
    Treadstone LawLegal commentary
    Is it worth paying for more than one valuation before I list?
    treadstonelaw.ca·Checked Aug 16, 2026
  4. 04
    Canada Revenue AgencyGovernment
    Selling a business
    canada.ca·Checked Aug 14, 2026

Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.