What grounds can a franchisor refuse a transfer on?
In Ontario, franchisors commonly review a buyer’s financial capacity, experience, other outlets and willingness to train, plus defaults on the seller’s account. In Ontario, whether a refusal can be challenged depends on your agreement’s wording and the good-faith duty in the Arthur Wishart Act.
In Ontario, almost every franchise agreement requires the franchisor’s consent before an outlet is transferred to a new owner, and that approval runs on its own timeline and its own criteria, separate from anything you and your buyer negotiate between yourselves. Ask the franchisor and your lawyer what grounds for a refusal your own agreement and the franchisor’s transfer process set; the sections below are questions to put to them.
What a franchisor commonly reviews
In Ontario, a franchisor’s review of a buyer usually includes financial information and business experience, and sometimes a personal interview. In Ontario, the points a franchisor commonly reviews before approving a buyer are these:
- Financial capacity to operate the business and meet ongoing franchise obligations
- Relevant business or industry experience
- Whether the buyer already operates other outlets, of this brand or a competitor
- Willingness to complete the franchisor’s training and meet its operating standards
- Whether any outstanding defaults or disputes on the seller’s account need to be resolved first
Whether a refusal has to be reasonable
In Ontario, franchise agreements vary widely in how much discretion they give the franchisor to refuse a transfer. Unlike the general commercial lease context, there is no broad statutory “not unreasonably withheld” rule specific to franchise transfers under Ontario law. In Ontario, whether a franchisor’s refusal can be challenged depends on the wording of your specific agreement and on the duty of good faith and fair dealing that the Arthur Wishart Act imposes on both franchisor and franchisee, so have a lawyer review your actual contract rather than assume either way.
A right of first refusal is a separate question
In Ontario, a franchisor right of first refusal is not usually a right to block your sale outright; it is a right to take your buyer’s place and buy the outlet on the same terms. In Ontario, if the franchisor waives it, your buyer still goes through the franchisor’s separate consent-to-transfer process. Ask your lawyer whether your agreement gives the franchisor this right.
What to do before marketing the business
Ask the franchisor, in writing, for its transfer criteria and for the notice it requires before a sale. In Ontario, most franchise agreements require notice well before a deal is meant to close. Ask your lawyer to check your own account with the franchisor for defaults or disputes that would need to be resolved first, and ask whether the lease needs the landlord’s consent as well as the franchisor’s.
Related reading
15 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Legal
- DefinitionFranchisor refusal grounds (reasonableness)
- DefinitionFranchise transfer
- Expert answerDo I need the franchisor’s permission to sell my franchise?
- Expert answerWho has to approve a franchise resale?
- Expert answerWhat happens to my franchise agreement when I sell?
- Expert answerCan a franchisor demand a share of my sale price?
- Expert answerCan a franchisor force a new buyer to renegotiate the whole agreement?
- Expert answerWhat is a change-of-control clause in a franchise agreement?
- Expert answerCan I be sued by the franchisor for selling without consent?
- Expert answerHow does a franchisor’s right of first refusal work when I sell?
- Expert answerCan a franchise be sold like any other business?
- Expert answerCan a franchisor take back my franchise location?
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryFranchisor Consent to Transfer
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryFranchisor Right of First Refusal in Ontario
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryBuying an Existing Franchise Resale in Ontario (Arthur Wishart Act)
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.