What happens if a warranty turns out to be wrong after closing?
In Ontario, a breach of warranty found after closing usually leads to an indemnity claim for money under the purchase agreement, rather than undoing the deal. Check the representation’s wording, the disclosure schedule, the survival period, the basket and the cap, then ask your lawyer.
An Ontario law firm says that in Ontario most purchase agreements are drafted so that a breach of representation or warranty gives rise to an indemnity claim, a claim for money to compensate the loss the breach caused, rather than a claim to void the deal. Ask your lawyer to read your own agreement.
First, check it is a breach
In Ontario, the same firm suggests checking the exact wording of the representation against what you have found. Ask your lawyer these questions:
- Did the seller actually warrant this specific thing, or is a general statement being stretched further than it was written?
- Is there a materiality qualifier (“in all material respects”) or a knowledge qualifier (“to the seller’s knowledge”) that narrows what was promised?
- Was the issue disclosed in the disclosure schedule? In Ontario, disclosed matters are usually carved out of the warranty’s protection.
Survival period, basket and cap
In Ontario, a survival period limits how long after closing a claim can still be brought. Check whether the window for the representation you are relying on has already closed.
In Ontario, a basket, sometimes called a deductible, filters out small claims. In Ontario, under a tipping basket, the buyer can generally claim the whole accumulated amount, threshold included. In Ontario, under a true deductible, the buyer can only claim the portion above the threshold. In Ontario, the indemnity cap sets the outer ceiling on total recoverable losses for capped categories of claims. Ask your lawyer which structure your agreement uses, and to read its operative language, not only the label.
In Ontario, certain categories of claims are commonly carved out of the basket, such as breaches of fundamental representations and specific indemnities negotiated for a known, disclosed issue, depending on how the agreement is drafted. Ask your lawyer whether any carve-out applies to your claim.
Where recovery can come from
In Ontario, an escrow or holdback is a portion of the purchase price withheld, or held by a third party, for a defined period, giving the buyer a ready source of funds to draw against once a claim within the basket and cap is established. Check your agreement for a holdback or an escrow, and ask your lawyer who else is bound by the seller’s representations. In Ontario, individual sellers in many transactions sign personal guarantees or are themselves parties to the representations, particularly on a share sale.
Quantify the loss and decide how to escalate
Write down what the breach has actually cost you, and keep the evidence of what you found and when. Ask your lawyer to check the agreement for how a claim must be raised, any notice requirement and any dispute mechanism, and whether the indemnity is the exclusive remedy. In Ontario, many agreements include a clause making the indemnity provisions the buyer’s exclusive remedy, subject to specific carve-outs, with fraud a common one.
Related reading
15 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Legal
- Expert answerWhat’s the difference between fundamental and general representations?
- GuideRepresentations, warranties and indemnities explained
- DefinitionIndemnity
- DefinitionSurvival period
- DefinitionIndemnity cap
- DefinitionBasket and de minimis
- DefinitionLimitation period for deal claims
- Expert answerHow long am I liable after selling my business?
- Expert answerWhat is an escrow holdback in a business sale?
- DefinitionEscrow release
Buying
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Treadstone LawLegal commentaryBreach of Warranty After Closing — Ontario Business Sale
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryBaskets and Deductibles in Business Sale Indemnities
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryBuyer Representations in a Business Purchase — ON
- 04Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.