What happens if an earn-out target is missed?
In Ontario, one law-firm article says the definitions of the earn-out metric, the measurement period and any operating covenants in the purchase agreement control what follows a missed target, not what feels fair. In Ontario, it lists common triggers for a dispute, such as a buyer changing pricing or product lines in ways that depress the metrics.
The first step is to read the earn-out clause itself, with a lawyer, before and after signing.
Start with the agreement’s wording
In Ontario, one law-firm article says that when a seller wants to challenge a missed target, the definitions of the earn-out metric, the measurement period and any operating covenants control the analysis, not what feels fair. Ask your lawyer to point to each of those three in your agreement and to explain in plain terms what the result would be if the target is missed by a little, or by a lot.
Who runs the business during the period
In Ontario, the same article says that once the deal closes, the buyer runs the business, including pricing, staffing, marketing spend, product mix and which customers to prioritize. In Ontario, it lists common triggers for a dispute, such as a buyer changing pricing, product lines or service offerings in ways that depress the metrics, disagreement over accounting methods used to calculate the metric, and a buyer diverting customers, referrals or resources to another part of its business.
Covenants and records to ask about
In Ontario, the article says a purchase agreement may include operating covenants limiting how the buyer may run the business during the earn-out period, such as restrictions on materially changing pricing or diverting business away from the acquired operation. In Ontario, it also says an agreement may require the buyer to operate the business in good faith, in the ordinary course, or without actions specifically intended to reduce the earn-out payment. Ask whether your agreement has any of these and how the buyer reports the figures to the seller during the period.
If a dispute starts
In Ontario, the article says to raise a dispute formally and promptly, because many agreements set deadlines for objecting to a proposed earn-out calculation and missing them can weaken or waive a position. In Ontario, it also says to gather evidence of the buyer’s post-closing decisions, such as pricing changes, staffing changes and diverted customers or contracts, and how they correlate with the shortfall, and that earn-out disputes are often resolved by negotiation, for example a partial payment, a revised structure or a lump-sum settlement.
In Ontario, a second law-firm article says unresolved financial disputes can be referred to an independent accountant if the agreement provides for it, and that earn-out disagreements may fall to arbitration or litigation instead, depending on what the parties agreed to. Ask whether your agreement names a process and how the cost would be allocated.
Related reading
12 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Selling
- Expert answerWhat happens in an earn-out dispute over underperformance?
- Expert answerHow are disputes over a contested earn-out payment resolved?
- Expert answerWhy is a longer earn-out period riskier?
- Expert answerCan a partner buyout be paid based on the business’s future performance?
- Expert answerHow is a working capital peg set in a business sale?
- Expert answerWhat happens if my business sale stalls?
Financing
Buying
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Treadstone LawLegal commentaryEarn-Out Disputes After a Business Sale in Ontario
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryEscrow Holdback vs. Vendor Take-Back in Ontario
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryDisputing a Post-Closing Price Adjustment — Ontario
- 04Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.