What can I do if the seller misrepresented the business?
In Ontario, if a seller’s representation turns out to be false, a post-closing indemnity claim can follow, but the disclosure schedule, survival period, basket, cap and any holdback or escrow all shape what is recoverable. Ask your lawyer to read your agreement.
This page describes Ontario business sales. If your business is elsewhere in Canada, check the rules where you are and ask a local lawyer. In Ontario, what a buyer can do about a false statement starts with the purchase agreement and the disclosure schedule attached to it, so ask your lawyer to read both before you act.
Start with the disclosure schedule
In Ontario, a disclosure schedule is an attachment to a share purchase agreement or an asset purchase agreement that lists specific facts, exceptions and qualifications to the representations and warranties the seller makes in the body of the agreement. A representation might read “there is no material litigation involving the business, except as disclosed in Schedule 6.4.” In Ontario, if a lawsuit is properly listed in that schedule, the representation is still true. In Ontario, if a lawsuit existed and was not listed, the representation is false, and that gap can become the basis of a post-closing indemnity claim.
Ask your lawyer to compare each item on the schedule with the representation number it is meant to qualify, and to confirm that the schedule reflects the business as it actually stood at signing and at closing.
Check the limits on an indemnity claim
In Ontario, a basket and a cap are two negotiated limits that decide how much of a loss, if any, is recoverable. In Ontario, the basket is a floor: if a loss, alone or combined with other qualifying claims, does not clear the negotiated threshold, it generally does not count toward a claim at all, unless it falls into a carve-out such as fraud or a specifically negotiated known issue. In Ontario, the cap is a ceiling: the buyer’s recovery for that category is limited to whatever cap applies, even where the actual loss is larger.
Check the survival period and the notice rules
In Ontario, a survival clause sets how long the representations and warranties keep operating after closing. In Ontario, once the survival period for a category has run out, an indemnity claim based on a breach of that category’s representations is generally barred going forward, even if new facts come to light afterward. Ask your lawyer what written notice the agreement requires, and by what date. In Ontario, missing a notice deadline can be just as fatal to a claim as missing the survival period itself.
Ask where the money would come from
In Ontario, where a holdback or escrow exists, recovery is typically pursued from it first, before the seller is chased directly for any remaining amount within the cap. Ask your lawyer when any holdback is scheduled to release, and whether a claim raised after that date could still be paid from it.
Remedies outside the contract
In Ontario, running out the survival period does not necessarily remove every remedy that might exist outside the contract; a genuinely fraudulent misrepresentation, for example, is often treated differently by a court. In Ontario, a court may also refuse to enforce a cap in a case of fraud, even where no carve-out was negotiated. Ask your lawyer whether the facts you have support a claim outside the agreement, and how any such claim interacts with the agreement’s own remedy provisions.
- Ask your lawyer to compare the disclosure schedule with each representation it qualifies
- Find the survival period for the category of representation involved, and the notice the agreement requires
- Find the basket, the cap and any carve-outs in the indemnity clause
- Find out whether a holdback or escrow exists, who holds it and when it is scheduled for release
Related reading
15 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Legal
- DefinitionRepresentations and warranties
- Expert answerWhat happens if a warranty turns out to be wrong after closing?
- DefinitionIndemnity
- DefinitionDisclosure schedule
- DefinitionSurvival period
- DefinitionSandbagging
- ChecklistSeller disclosure checklist
- GuideThe purchase agreement, clause by clause
- DefinitionPost-closing dispute
Selling
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryDisclosure Schedules in an Ontario Business Sale Agreement
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryIndemnity Baskets and Caps in an Ontario Business Sale
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Long Do Representations and Warranties Survive After an Ontario Business Sale?
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.