What do I do if I find a problem during due diligence?
Get the problem confirmed by your accountant or lawyer before deciding anything. BDC says to take due diligence findings seriously rather than dismiss them, and to consider ways to mitigate the risks they uncover. Ask your lawyer what your agreement lets you do.
BDC’s due diligence article says it is important to take findings seriously, and that some buyers make the mistake of dismissing information that challenges their enthusiasm about the transaction, only to regret it later. It also says it is normal for some conflicting information to arise. Before you act on a finding, check what your agreement says about it.
First, confirm what you are looking at
BDC says that if sales are trending downward and the vendor cannot convincingly explain why, you may need to rethink the transaction, and that due diligence is about trust and verification: making sure the numbers match the reality on the ground. Ask the seller to explain the finding in writing, ask for the documents behind the explanation, and ask your accountant or lawyer whether the explanation holds.
Check what your agreement says
In Ontario, a due diligence completion condition is a condition that the buyer’s review turns up nothing that materially changes the deal, often phrased as the buyer being “satisfied, in its sole discretion” with the results. In Ontario, if a condition benefiting one party has not been satisfied or waived by the outside date, the usual consequences are that the party it benefits can terminate without being in breach, or the parties may agree to extend the outside date or negotiate a waiver, often paired with a price adjustment or added protection for whichever side is giving something up, and deposit or exclusivity provisions may be triggered depending on how the agreement allocates the consequences of a failed condition. In Ontario, whether a failed condition allows only termination or also supports a damages claim depends heavily on how the agreement is drafted.
Ask your lawyer whether your agreement has a due diligence condition, who it benefits, what the outside date is, and what happens to any deposit if the condition fails.
Questions to put to your lawyer
BDC says that, with your lawyer’s help, you use due diligence to finalize the purchase agreement, and that legal and commercial due diligence help you account for red flags such as pending litigation, tax liabilities, assets in less than good working order and unsigned contracts. BDC also says to consider ways to mitigate the risks your due diligence uncovered; for key employees, it suggests thinking about employment contracts with incentives to remain.
- Ask whether the finding changes the price structure. BDC’s article on negotiating a purchase agreement says you may need to negotiate a different price structure based on your due diligence, and that you will typically decide how much of the price is held back in escrow or made subject to conditions.
- Ask whether an indemnity should cover the finding. BDC says the indemnities section sets the compensation the vendor pays if disclosures turn out to be inaccurate or covenants are not respected, and that the seller’s liability is typically capped. In Ontario, a basket is a minimum amount of loss that has to accumulate before a claim counts, and a cap is the maximum total amount recoverable; ask how both would apply to the issue you found.
- Ask whether the seller can fix the issue before closing. BDC says closing conditions can include remedial actions, such as cleaning up corporate or environmental issues flagged during due diligence.
- Ask whether you can walk away. BDC says due diligence may uncover information that could change your perception of the deal and even make you walk away; ask your lawyer what rights your agreement gives you.
- Ask how recovery would work if a loss surfaces after closing. In Ontario, an article on baskets and caps describes recovery as typically pursued from the holdback or escrow first, if one exists, before the seller is pursued directly for any remaining amount within the cap.
Get it in writing
Whatever you decide, ask your lawyer to make sure the written agreement reflects it. BDC’s steps-to-buying article says the finalized purchase agreement will include the scope of the transaction, payment terms, any indemnifications and warranties, and an employment agreement if the seller will remain for a transition period. Ask the seller to confirm in writing any explanation they gave you for the issue. If the finding is about taxes, CRA’s page on selling a business lists the business number, payroll, GST/HST and change of ownership; ask your accountant which apply.
Related reading
15 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Due diligence
Buying
Selling
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryIndemnity Baskets and Caps in an Ontario Business Sale
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryConditions Precedent to Closing in an Ontario Business Sale Agreement
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Long Does Due Diligence Take When Buying a Business in Ontario?
- 05Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernmentHow to conduct due diligence when buying a business
- 06Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernmentMajor pitfalls to avoid when negotiating a purchase agreement
- 07Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernmentWhat are the steps to buying a business?
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.