What do I do if I get more than one offer?
Before you answer any of several offers, ask your lawyer and broker what your listing agreement says, what you may tell each buyer, and how you will compare structure, conditions and evidence of funds as well as price. Give every buyer the same written deadline.
Before you reply to any of the offers, ask your lawyer and your broker, if you have one, to go through the same short list of questions, so that every buyer is treated the same way. The points about listing agreements and brokers come from two Ontario law firm articles.
Ask what your listing agreement says
In Ontario, an article on listing agreements with a business broker says most are either exclusive, giving one broker the sole right to market and sell your business for the term, or non-exclusive. Ask your lawyer whether your agreement is exclusive, whether it carves out named prospects you already knew, and whether it restricts you from contacting buyers directly during the term.
In Ontario, the article says a tail or holdover clause typically requires you to pay the broker’s commission if a buyer they introduced during the listing period buys the business within a defined period after the agreement ends. Ask your broker which of the buyers it introduced, and ask your lawyer how long the tail runs. In Ontario, the article says the agreement should specify that prospective buyers sign a confidentiality agreement before receiving detailed information, so ask your broker to confirm that each buyer making an offer has signed one.
Ask what you may say to each buyer
Ask your lawyer what you may tell one buyer about another buyer’s offer, if anything, and what any confidentiality agreement or letter of intent you have already signed says about it. Ask whether a letter of intent signed with one buyer limits your dealings with the others.
Ask every buyer for the same things in writing
- How much is paid in cash at closing and how much is paid later, and on what terms.
- Evidence of funds or financing status: money on hand, a written loan approval, or financing still to be arranged.
- Every condition attached to the offer, with its deadline.
- The closing date proposed and what has to happen before it.
- Who will act for the buyer, such as its lawyer and accountant.
Ask how the comparison will be run
In Ontario, an article on brokers and M&A advisors says brokers typically run a fairly standardized marketing and sale process, and that an M&A advisor tends to run a more customized, competitive process, often approaching a curated list of buyers. In Ontario, it lists wanting to run a genuinely competitive process among several potential buyers as a reason to consider an M&A advisor. In Ontario, the same article says a more competitive, structured process does not automatically mean a higher price, because the result still depends heavily on the business’s own fundamentals and market conditions.
Ask your broker how it would run a process among the buyers you have, and ask whether an M&A advisor would handle it differently. Ask your lawyer and accountant to review the offers side by side before you choose.
Ask about a deadline for final offers
Ask your lawyer and broker whether to give every buyer the same written date for final offers, and what you will say to a buyer who asks for more time. Ask what your listing agreement and any letter of intent allow you to do while you wait.
Related reading
11 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Selling
Legal
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryListing Agreement With a Business Broker in Ontario
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryBusiness Broker vs. M&A Advisor in Ontario
- 04Canadian Federation of Independent BusinessResearch dataSuccession Tsunami: Preparing for a decade of small business transitions
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.