What if the financials do not match the tax returns?
Ask the seller’s accountant to explain each difference between the financial statements and the filed CRA tax returns, year by year and in writing, and ask for the returns and notices of assessment. In Ontario, a legal guide says to treat a seller’s summary as a starting point, not a substitute for the underlying statements and tax filings.
Ask the seller to explain, in writing and year by year, any difference between the financial statements shown to you and the tax returns filed with the Canada Revenue Agency. This page lists what to request and whom to ask. It does not say what a gap means in your case.
Start with the documents
In Ontario, a guide to reading financial statements says to treat a seller’s summary as a starting point, not a substitute for the underlying financial statements and tax filings. In Ontario, an article on CRA debts lists copies of recent corporate income tax filings and notices of assessment among the documents to review, together with confirmation of any active CRA audit, reassessment or payment arrangement. Ask the seller for the filed returns and notices of assessment for each year the statements cover, and set them beside the statements.
Ask what kind of statements you have
In Ontario, the guide to reading financial statements says compiled (notice to reader) statements are put together by an accountant from the owner’s records with no verification, and are the lowest level of assurance. In Ontario, it says review-engagement statements involve limited analytical procedures, that audited statements involve independent, in-depth verification, and that most small Ontario businesses for sale will only have compiled or review-engagement statements. In Ontario, it adds that you and your accountant should factor the lower assurance level into how much independent verification you do yourselves. Ask which kind you have been given and who prepared it.
Questions for the seller’s accountant
- Ask for a line-by-line reconciliation of each difference, year by year, in writing.
- Ask which items are treated differently in the statements than in the return, and why.
- Ask whether any correction was made after the return was filed, and whether an amended return was filed.
- Ask which expenses the owner has added back, and for the records behind each one.
- In Ontario, the guide to reading financial statements says many small business owners pay themselves in ways that do not reflect a market-rate manager’s salary, which affects how you interpret profit. Ask how reported profit compares once owner compensation and one-time items are normalized.
- In Ontario, the same guide asks whether there are any tax filings, assessments or disputes that could become the buyer’s problem. Put that question to the seller in writing.
Involve your own accountant and lawyer
Ask your own accountant, not only the seller’s, to make the comparison. If a difference cannot be explained, ask your lawyer how to proceed before you rely on either set of numbers.
In Ontario, the CRA debts article says Canadian tax law includes rules that can, in certain circumstances, make a person who receives property from someone who owes tax debts responsible for that debt, up to the value of what they received, particularly where the transfer is not at arm’s length or is not for full value. In Ontario, it also says a return can be filed on time while the associated payment is outstanding, and advises getting seller representations and indemnities addressing pre-closing tax liabilities, regardless of what the records show. Ask your lawyer whether and how your agreement should address them.
Related reading
15 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Due diligence
- Expert answerWhat financial records should I ask a seller for?
- Expert answerHow do I check whether a business actually makes money?
- Expert answerHow do I check a business for unpaid taxes?
- Expert answerHow do I check a business’s books before buying it?
- Expert answerHow do I verify a seller’s financial statements?
- ChecklistFinancial records checklist for buyers
- ChecklistDeal red flags checklist
Valuation
Selling
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow to Read a Business's Financial Statements Before You Buy in Ontario
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryChecking for Outstanding CRA Debts Before Buying a Business in Ontario
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.