What if there is a lawsuit against the business I am buying?
In Ontario, a lawsuit against the business can be listed on the disclosure schedule that qualifies the seller’s representations. In Ontario, if it is listed, the no-litigation representation stays true; if it existed and was not listed, the representation is false and can support a post-closing indemnity claim.
If you find a lawsuit against the business during due diligence, ask the seller for the claim documents, any settlement correspondence and the name of the lawyer handling it. Then ask where the lawsuit is recorded in the draft purchase agreement.
Ask where the lawsuit appears in the agreement
In Ontario, purchase agreements are typically drafted with broad, general representations, such as that there is no material undisclosed litigation. In Ontario, a disclosure schedule is an attachment that lists specific facts, exceptions and qualifications to the seller’s representations and warranties, and existing or threatened litigation and claims involving the business are among the things that typically go into it. Ask the seller’s lawyer to show you the schedule and the representation it qualifies.
How a listed and an unlisted lawsuit are treated in Ontario
In Ontario, a representation might read that there is no material litigation involving the business, except as disclosed in a numbered schedule. In Ontario, if a lawsuit is properly listed in that schedule, the representation is still true, because the buyer bought the business knowing about it. In Ontario, if a lawsuit existed and was not listed, the representation is false, and that gap can become the basis of a post-closing indemnity claim.
Compare the lawsuit documents you were given with the wording of the schedule, line by line, and ask your lawyer whether the listing describes the claim fully.
Holdbacks, thresholds and caps
In Ontario, when an indemnity claim is made and a holdback or escrow exists, recovery is pursued from the holdback or escrow first, before the seller is chased directly for any remaining amount within the cap. In Ontario, a loss that, alone or combined with other qualifying claims, does not clear the negotiated threshold generally does not count toward a claim at all, unless it falls into a carve-out that bypasses the threshold, such as fraud or a specifically negotiated known issue.
Questions to put to the seller and your lawyer
- Ask the seller for the claim documents and for a written update on where the lawsuit stands.
- Ask the seller whether any insurer has responded to the claim, and for a copy of that correspondence.
- Ask your lawyer whether a specific term in the agreement should deal with this lawsuit, rather than leaving it to the general indemnity provisions.
- Ask your lawyer whether the cap structure treats a specific known risk differently from routine operational matters, or lumps everything under one number.
- Ask your lawyer whether drawing on the holdback counts against the cap, and check what your specific agreement says.
- Ask your lawyer whether the deal is a share sale or an asset sale, and what that means for this claim.
Related reading
12 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Legal
- Expert answerWhat happens if I inherit a lawsuit with the business?
- Expert answerWhat can I do if the seller misrepresented the business?
- DefinitionDisclosure schedule
- DefinitionIndemnity
- DefinitionAsset sale
- DefinitionRepresentations and warranties
- DefinitionIndemnity cap
- Expert answerWhat director liability do I take on in a share purchase?
Buying
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryDisclosure Schedules in an Ontario Business Sale Agreement
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryIndemnity Baskets and Caps in an Ontario Business Sale
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryCorporate Law
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.