Attornment to jurisdiction (forum clause)
Attornment to jurisdiction, also called attorning to the jurisdiction, is a party’s submission to a particular court’s authority to decide a dispute, either by agreeing in the contract that the court has jurisdiction (a forum clause) or by submitting to its jurisdiction during the proceeding. This entry looks at how British Columbia and Ontario treat that agreement.
When a buyer and seller live in different provinces, the purchase agreement may name the courts of one province for disputes. That choice of forum is separate from the governing law clause, which picks the rules applied to the contract. The two examples below show how British Columbia’s statute and Ontario’s court rules deal with a forum clause. For other provinces and territories, check the rules where the claim would be brought.
Two provincial examples
British Columbia’s Court Jurisdiction and Proceedings Transfer Act gives a British Columbia court territorial competence in a proceeding brought against a person only in listed cases, subject to a residual discretion in section 6 to hear a proceeding where there is no court outside British Columbia in which the plaintiff can commence it, or commencing it there cannot reasonably be required. Two of the listed cases are that the person submits to the court’s jurisdiction during the proceeding, and that there is an agreement between the plaintiff and that person to the effect that the court has jurisdiction. Under section 11 the court may still decline to exercise that competence if a court elsewhere is a more appropriate forum.
In Ontario, rule 17.02 of the Rules of Civil Procedure lets a party be served outside Ontario without a court order in a claim about a contract where, among other listed grounds, the parties have agreed that the courts of Ontario are to have jurisdiction. Under rule 17.06 the party served may move, before delivering a defence, notice of intent to defend or notice of appearance, to set aside the service or stay the proceeding, and the court may grant that if, among other grounds, Ontario is not a convenient forum.
What to ask
- Which courts does the agreement name, and is the clause exclusive or optional?
- Does it match the governing law clause?
- Does it sit alongside an arbitration or mediation step?
Related reading: claims against the seller after closing and the governing law clause.
Sources
This definition is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Government of British Columbia (BC Laws)GovernmentCourt Jurisdiction and Proceedings Transfer Act
- 02Government of OntarioGovernmentR.R.O. 1990, Reg. 194: Rules of Civil Procedure
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.