Unjust enrichment
Unjust enrichment is a claim to recover the value of a benefit someone else kept without a legal reason to keep it. Under the common law, the Supreme Court of Canada describes three elements: an enrichment, a corresponding deprivation, and no juristic reason.
A person who paid money or did work for another, and who has no contract covering it, may look to unjust enrichment. In a business setting that could be money or effort put into a deal or an operation that did not turn out as expected. It is a remedy a court may grant, not a right to be paid on demand.
How the test works
In Garland v. Consumers’ Gas, the Supreme Court of Canada stated the test as an enrichment of the defendant, a corresponding deprivation of the plaintiff, and an absence of juristic reason for the enrichment. Garland describes the juristic reason analysis in two parts, and the Court repeated the three elements and the two-stage analysis in Moore v. Sweet. The established categories of juristic reason in Garland include a contract, a disposition of law, a donative intent, and other valid common law, equitable or statutory obligations. If none applies, the plaintiff has a prima facie case, which the defendant can rebut by showing another reason to deny recovery. These are common-law rules.
In Quebec, article 1493 of the Civil Code requires a person enriched at the expense of another to indemnify the other for the correlative impoverishment, to the extent of the enrichment, if there is no justification for the enrichment or the impoverishment. Article 1494 sets out when they are justified, such as where they result from the performance of an obligation, and article 1495 makes the indemnity due only if the enrichment still exists on the day of the demand.
What to check or ask
- Whether a written agreement already covers the payment or the work, since a contract is one established juristic reason
- What was paid or done, and who received the benefit
- Whether any time limit for starting a claim has begun to run
Compare what happens if a buyer walks away before closing and privity of contract.
Sources
This definition is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Supreme Court of CanadaCourt decisionGarland v. Consumers' Gas Co., 2004 SCC 25, [2004] 1 SCR 629 (Internet Archive capture of 2022-10-12)
- 02Supreme Court of CanadaCourt decisionMoore v. Sweet, 2018 SCC 52, [2018] 3 SCR 303 (Internet Archive capture of 2024-04-03)
- 03Éditeur officiel du QuébecGovernmentCCQ-1991 - Civil Code of Québec
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.