Earn-outs, explained
A CRA bulletin on shares sold subject to an earnout agreement describes an earnout as a clause where the amount of proceeds is determined by reference to future earnings generated by the underlying assets of the corporation. Ask your lawyer how your agreement defines it.
Ask your lawyer to explain, in plain words and before you sign, exactly how any earn-out in your agreement is measured, who controls the business while it runs, and what happens if the two sides disagree. This page sets out what its cited sources say about earn-outs and related payment arrangements, and turns the rest into questions to ask. It does not say what an earn-out should be, or what any figure should be.
What the Canada Revenue Agency bulletin says an earn-out is
The Canada Revenue Agency has an archived interpretation bulletin, IT-426R, titled Shares Sold Subject to an Earnout Agreement. The Agency says it archived the page and will not update it, and that it can be used for research or reference. The bulletin deals with shares of a corporation sold under an agreement whereby the proceeds of disposition are at least partially determined pursuant to an earnout clause, that is, where the quantum of proceeds is determined by reference to future earnings generated by the underlying assets of the corporation.
The bulletin says that, for its purposes, an agreement that merely determines when amounts are to be paid, as opposed to determining the quantum of proceeds, is not considered to be an earnout agreement. Ask your lawyer to say which of the two your agreement describes. The bulletin is about how a vendor reports a capital gain or loss, and it sets out conditions for the method it describes. Ask your accountant whether the bulletin, which is archived, still bears on your sale, and what the current rules are for the tax treatment of any amount you have not yet received.
Ask what the earn-out is measured against
- Ask which measure decides the additional amount, and ask your lawyer to put the definition of that measure in the agreement in writing.
- Ask which financial statements or records the measure is taken from, who prepares them and how often they are shared.
- Ask for the period over which the measure is tested, and what happens to the period if the business changes during it.
- Ask whether the agreement sets a minimum amount that is payable in any event and a maximum that could become payable. The bulletin refers to both in its tax reporting rules, so ask your accountant how each is treated.
- Ask whether the amount is tiered or is a single figure, and ask your lawyer to set out a worked example in the agreement.
Ask who runs the business while the earn-out runs
Ask your lawyer what the agreement says about decisions made after closing that could change the measured result, such as how costs are recorded and whether the business is combined with another one. Ask the seller, if the seller is staying involved, what role and authority the seller will have, and ask the buyer who will make those decisions. Ask whether the agreement requires the business to be run in a particular way during the period, and what each side can do if it believes the other has not followed that requirement.
Ask how disagreements get resolved
In Ontario, a law firm’s article on escrow and holdbacks says purchase agreements typically set out how disputes are resolved, often by referral to an independent accountant for financial or working-capital disagreements, or by arbitration or litigation for other indemnity disputes. That article is about holdbacks and indemnity, not earn-outs, so ask your lawyer what process the agreement sets for a disagreement over the earn-out calculation, and who decides it.
How an earn-out differs from a holdback or a vendor take-back
In Ontario, a law firm’s article on escrow and holdbacks says a portion of the price is often held back, either in escrow with a neutral third party or as a holdback managed under the purchase agreement itself, to protect the buyer if something turns out to be wrong after closing. In Ontario, the same article says that what matters more than the label is what the document says about how much is held, for how long and what releases it. In Ontario, a law firm’s article on securing a vendor take-back loan describes a vendor take-back as the seller financing part of the purchase price instead of collecting it all in cash at closing, and says that without security it is an unsecured loan.
Ask your lawyer to say, for each amount that is not paid in cash at closing, whether it is an earn-out, a holdback or escrow, or a vendor take-back, and what the agreement says decides whether and when it is paid. In Ontario, a law firm’s article on survival periods says purchase agreements frequently line up the release of a holdback with the relevant survival period. Ask your lawyer whether an earn-out and a holdback in your agreement can be set against each other, and in what order.
Questions for your lawyer and accountant
- Does the agreement define the measure, the period and the reporting, in writing?
- Who controls the business during the period, and what limits, if any, apply to that control?
- Is there a minimum, a maximum, or both?
- In Ontario, what process does the agreement set for resolving a disagreement over the calculation?
- How is any amount that has not yet been received treated for tax, and is the Canada Revenue Agency bulletin still relevant?
Related reading
10 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Selling
Sources
Every requirement and figure referenced in this guide traces to a primary source. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryEscrow and Holdbacks in an Ontario Business Sale
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryIndemnity Baskets and Caps in an Ontario Business Sale
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Long Do Representations and Warranties Survive After an Ontario Business Sale?
- 05Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Sellers Secure a Vendor Take-Back Loan in an Ontario Business Sale
- 06Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentARCHIVED - Shares Sold Subject to an Earnout Agreement
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.