Deavo
LegalGuide · 5 min read

Non-competes in an asset sale vs a share sale

The structure decides who sells, so it helps decide who should sign the covenant: a corporation that owns the business in an asset sale, the shareholders in a share sale. Section 56.4 of the Income Tax Act frames its exceptions differently for each, so ask your tax adviser.

A non-compete is only as useful as the person who signs it. If a corporation owns the business, it is the seller in an asset sale. In a share sale, the sellers are the shareholders. Who gives the covenant, and what tax paperwork applies to it, starts from that. This guide is for a buyer or seller drafting the purchase agreement. It covers who should be named as giving the covenant, how section 56.4 of the Income Tax Act is framed for goodwill and for shares, why allocation matters, and what Ontario adds for staff who stay on. It is general information, not tax or legal advice.

Who sells, and so who gives the covenant

In an asset sale of a business a corporation owns, the corporation sells the business property, so it is a party to the agreement. It may not be the only person whose competition worries the buyer. The owner who holds the customer relationships may be a shareholder rather than a party, so check. In a share sale, the shareholders are the sellers and sign the agreement, and the corporation stays in place under new ownership. The question is then whether each seller gives a covenant personally. Our guide to asset sales versus share sales explains the wider structural differences.

Owners and related corporations: what to check

List everyone who could compete with the business after closing, then check whether each one is bound. In an asset sale, ask whether the individual owners, their spouses or other family members, and any holding company or sister corporation are parties or have signed a joinder. In a share sale, ask whether every shareholder, including minority holders, is signing, and whether a corporation that holds shares is giving the covenant alongside its own owners. Ask your lawyer whether a covenant signed by the corporation also binds the person who runs it, and whether one that names only the individual reaches a company they control.

Section 56.4(3)(b): covenants tied to goodwill

Section 56.4(2) of the Income Tax Act includes amounts received or receivable for a restrictive covenant in income. Section 56.4(3) lists cases where that inclusion does not apply to an amount. Each requires that the covenant is granted to a purchaser with whom the seller deals at arm’s length (determined without reference to paragraph 251(5)(b)). Paragraph (b) covers an amount that would, reading the Act without section 56.4, be required to be included in the proceeds of disposition of Class 14.1 property, or is an amount to which subsection 13(38) applies, in respect of the business the covenant relates to. It also requires an election in prescribed form. Where the amount is payable by the purchaser in respect of a business the purchaser carries on in Canada, the seller and purchaser must elect jointly. Paragraph (b) is framed around Class 14.1 property and subsection 13(38) amounts, not around shares.

Section 56.4(3)(c): covenants tied to shares

Paragraph (c) is framed around a different event: the amount must directly relate to the covenant giver’s disposition of an eligible interest, a defined term in the section, in the partnership or corporation that carries on the business, or in a holding corporation covered by that definition. The disposition must be to the purchaser or a person related to the purchaser. The amount must be consideration for an undertaking not to provide, directly or indirectly, property or services in competition with those provided or to be provided by the purchaser or a person related to the purchaser, and the covenant must reasonably be considered to have been granted to maintain or preserve the value of the interest sold. Further conditions concern subsection 84(3) and adding the amount to proceeds of disposition, and the seller and purchaser must elect in prescribed form. The paragraph is subject to subsection (9), which says it does not apply to an amount that would, reading the Act without subsections (2) to (14), be included in computing a taxpayer’s income from an office or employment or a business or property under paragraph 3(a). Under subsection (13), the election is to include a copy of the covenant and be filed with the Minister by the deadline that subsection sets.

Allocating the price under section 68

Section 68 applies where an amount received or receivable can reasonably be regarded as being in part the consideration for the disposition of a property, for services, or for a restrictive covenant. The part that can reasonably be regarded as consideration for the covenant is deemed to be an amount received or receivable in respect of it, irrespective of the form or legal effect of the contract or agreement. Subsection 56.4(5) says that where it applies, section 68 does not deem consideration to be received for the covenant; subsections (6) and (7) describe those cases, and subsection (7) is subject to subsection (10). Our glossary entry on restrictive covenant tax rules gives a plain-language start. Ask your tax adviser how the parties should treat the allocation.

Staff who stay: Ontario employee covenants

This section covers Ontario only; check the rules where you are. Section 67.2(1) of the Employment Standards Act, 2000 says no employer shall enter into an employment contract or other agreement with an employee that is or includes a non-compete agreement, and subsection (2) makes a non-compliant one void. Subsection (3) says that where there is a sale of a business or part of one, the purchaser and seller agree as part of the sale that the seller will not compete after the sale, and the seller becomes the purchaser’s employee immediately after the sale, subsection (1) does not apply to that agreement. Subsection (4) separately exempts employees who are executives, as the Act defines them. A covenant for an employee who is not the seller is a different question.

  • Name the party giving the covenant, and say whether individual owners, family members and related corporations are bound as well.
  • Ask your tax adviser whether the amount fits section 56.4(3)(b) or (c), and whether a joint election is required.
  • Decide with your lawyer how the price is allocated, remembering that section 68 looks at what can reasonably be regarded as consideration.
  • In Ontario, check whether a staff covenant is caught by section 67.2 or falls within its sale exception.
  • Keep the wording clear: Martin v. ConCreate, a 2013 Court of Appeal for Ontario decision, addressed whether covenants were ambiguous and whether blue-pencil or notional severance applied.

Sources

Every requirement and figure referenced in this guide traces to a primary source. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.

  1. 01
    Government of Canada (Department of Justice)Government
    Income Tax Act, section 56.4 (restrictive covenants)
    laws-lois.justice.gc.ca·Checked Nov 4, 2026
  2. 02
    Government of Canada (Department of Justice)Government
    Income Tax Act, section 68 (allocation of amounts in consideration for property, services or restrictive covenants)
    laws-lois.justice.gc.ca·Checked Oct 25, 2026
  3. 03
    Government of OntarioGovernment
    Employment Standards Act, 2000, S.O. 2000, c. 41
    ontario.ca·Checked Oct 20, 2026
  4. 04
    Court of Appeal for OntarioCourt decision
    Martin v. ConCreate USL Limited Partnership, 2013 ONCA 72
    ontariocourts.ca·Checked Nov 4, 2026
  5. 05
    Canada Revenue AgencyGovernment
    Restrictive covenant
    canada.ca·Checked Oct 24, 2026

Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.