Deavo
LegalGuide · 5 min read

Non-solicitation clauses in a business sale

A non-solicit in a purchase agreement is a separate promise not to approach the customers, and sometimes the staff, who stay with the business. Ontario appeal decisions test its words against what protects the goodwill bought, and the Competition Act can catch a promise not to hire.

A non-solicit in a purchase agreement is a promise about people: the seller will not approach the customers, and sometimes the employees, who stay with the business the buyer has paid for. It is a separate clause from a non-compete, with its own wording, and its exact words matter: the Ontario appeal decisions below turned on what a clause actually covered and how long it ran. This guide covers what Ontario appeal decisions say about these clauses, what Ontario’s employment-standards guide says about non-solicits, how the Competition Act treats promises not to hire, and the questions to put to a draft. The sources are Ontario and federal; if the business is elsewhere, check the rules where it is.

Customer non-solicits: what a court looked at

In Mason v. Chem-Trend, the Court of Appeal for Ontario considered an employment covenant that barred a former employee, for a period after he left, from competing by supplying or soliciting any business that had been a customer of the company while he worked there. The court found the covenant overly broad and unenforceable. It noted that the employee had worked there for many years, the company had world-wide operations, and he had no access to its very large customer list, so he had no way to know whether a given contact was on the prohibited list. It also noted that he was barred not just from soliciting those customers but from any dealing with them in competition with the company, and it recorded counsel’s acknowledgement that having him ask the company to vet each contact would be unworkable. That was an employment case, and the result turned on its facts.

The same reasoning in a sale

In Martin v. ConCreate, the covenants were given in connection with a sale transaction. In a finding it said was not determinative of the appeal, the Court of Appeal found the non-solicitation clause extended to communicating or dealing with any persons who were customers, dealers, agents or distributors at the time of the sale “or afterwards”, and said it went “far beyond what was properly required to adequately protect the goodwill of the purchased business”. It added that it was not reasonable for a covenant given on a sale “to extend to activities neither carried on nor in the parties’ contemplation at the time of sale”. The key issue was duration: the court held the term unreasonable because it depended on third parties’ consents and had no fixed outside limit, and it agreed the non-compete and non-solicit could not be saved by blue-pencil or notional severance, so both fell. A separate confidentiality clause in the same agreement was upheld. Again, the outcome rested on that agreement’s wording.

Sale versus employment, and what that does not decide

In MEDIchair v. DME Medequip, the Court of Appeal, describing two Supreme Court of Canada decisions, said that, although the test for restrictive covenants is essentially the same, courts give more scrutiny to the reasonableness of a covenant in the employment context, “while applying a presumption of validity” to covenants negotiated as part of the sale of a business. Martin shows the limit: the sale context did not save covenants whose duration had no fixed outside limit, and the court said Mason’s reasoning on scope was still apt in a sale. Read the two together as reasons to define the protected relationships precisely, not as a promise that a sale clause will be enforced. For the wider comparison, see non-compete vs non-solicit.

Employee non-solicits and Ontario’s ESA

The Martin clause also restricted soliciting employees. Ontario’s guide to the Employment Standards Act defines a non-compete as a prohibition on engaging in activity in competition with the employer’s business after the employment ends, and says the Act prohibits non-competes, subject to two exceptions (one on a sale of a business, one for executives), but does not prohibit non-solicit or non-disclosure agreements, directing questions about their enforceability to a lawyer. It adds that the substance of an agreement is what matters, not the words used, and gives an example where a clause headed “Non-Competition” only barred contacting customers, which the guide treats as about soliciting, not a non-compete. The guide’s sale exception covers a sale or lease of a business, or part of one, operated as a sole proprietorship or partnership, where the seller becomes the buyer’s employee immediately after the sale. So if the seller will stay on as an employee, ask a lawyer how that exception and any customer or staff restriction fit together. The glossary entry on a non-solicitation clause gives the short definition.

No-hire promises and the Competition Act

Section 45(1.1) of the Competition Act makes it an offence for an employer to conspire, agree or arrange with another employer that is not affiliated with it not to solicit or hire each other’s employees. Under section 45(4), no person is convicted if that person establishes, on a balance of probabilities, that the restraint is ancillary to a broader or separate agreement or arrangement that includes the same parties and is directly related to, and reasonably necessary for giving effect to, its objective, and the broader or separate agreement, considered alone, does not contravene the subsection. The Competition Bureau’s collaboration guidelines, which discuss the ancillary restraints defence, list a non-compete in a sale of assets or shares as an example of an ancillary restraint; the list does not mention a no-hire promise. Ask a lawyer how the Bureau treats a no-hire term in a sale. See pay and hiring under the Competition Act.

Questions to put to the draft

  • Who is bound, and who is protected: the seller personally, its owners, related companies, and only the business sold or also the buyer’s other operations?
  • What counts as soliciting: active approaches only, or any dealing? In Mason, the court treated a bar on any dealing with former customers, not just soliciting them, as overly broad.
  • Which customers are named or described, and could the seller work out from the clause who is covered without asking the buyer? Does it reach customers who arrive after closing?
  • For employees: is it a promise not to approach them, or not to hire them at all, and does a general job advertisement count? Has a competition lawyer looked at any no-hire term?
  • How long does each restriction run, and does it have a fixed outside limit? In Martin, a term that ran while the seller held an interest whose transfer needed third parties’ consent had none.

Sources

Every requirement and figure referenced in this guide traces to a primary source. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.

  1. 01
    Court of Appeal for OntarioCourt decision
    Mason v. Chem-Trend Limited Partnership, 2011 ONCA 344
    ontariocourts.ca·Checked Nov 4, 2026
  2. 02
    Court of Appeal for OntarioCourt decision
    Martin v. ConCreate USL Limited Partnership, 2013 ONCA 72
    ontariocourts.ca·Checked Nov 4, 2026
  3. 03
    Court of Appeal for OntarioCourt decision
    MEDIchair LP v. DME Medequip Inc., 2016 ONCA 168
    ontariocourts.ca·Checked Nov 4, 2026
  4. 04
    Government of Ontario — Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills DevelopmentGovernment
    Non-compete agreements — Your guide to the Employment Standards Act
    ontario.ca·Checked Oct 24, 2026
  5. 05
    Government of CanadaGovernment
    Competition Act
    laws-lois.justice.gc.ca·Checked Aug 16, 2026
  6. 06
    Competition Bureau CanadaGovernment
    Competitor Collaboration Guidelines
    competition-bureau.canada.ca·Checked Oct 24, 2026

Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.