Seller non-competes when you sell a business
A non-compete given in a business sale protects a legitimate interest: the goodwill the buyer is purchasing from the seller. The Court of Appeal for Ontario treats a covenant given in a sale less strictly than an employee’s, but still tests it for reasonableness.
If you are selling your business, the draft purchase agreement may ask you to promise not to compete afterwards. The Court of Appeal for Ontario has said a covenant given in a sale “may be required to protect the goodwill sold to the purchaser”. This guide explains what the buyer is protecting, how Ontario courts have looked at these covenants, and what to read before you sign. It is general information, not advice on your agreement.
Why the buyer asks
In MEDIchair v. DME Medequip, the Court of Appeal for Ontario quoted the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision in Elsley: a person selling a business “might find himself with an unsaleable commodity if denied the right to assure the purchaser that he, the vendor, would not later enter into competition.” The covenant is that assurance. In Martin v. ConCreate, the Court of Appeal for Ontario noted that the law distinguishes a covenant given in a sale from one between an employer and an employee, because the former may be required to protect the goodwill sold and “does not usually involve the imbalance of power that exists between employer and employee”. When you are asked to sign, the useful question is what goodwill the buyer is actually buying from you, because, as MEDIchair describes the test from Payette v. Guay, the clause must be limited in term, territory and activities to whatever is necessary to protect the legitimate interests of the party it was granted to.
How courts treat a sale covenant compared with an employee’s
In MEDIchair v. DME Medequip, the Court of Appeal for Ontario said the test is essentially the same for a covenant in a sale of a business and one in an employment contract. It added that courts give more scrutiny to the reasonableness of an employment covenant, and apply a presumption of validity to a covenant negotiated as part of a sale. Describing the Supreme Court’s decision in Payette v. Guay, it said that in the commercial context, the sale of a business, a covenant is treated as lawful unless it is shown, on a balance of probabilities, to be unreasonable. Mason v. Chem-Trend, an employee case, describing the Supreme Court’s decision in Shafron, reports the same difference: stricter scrutiny for an employment covenant than for one that is part of the consideration for a sale.
A sale covenant is still tested
Martin v. ConCreate shows that a lighter test is not no test. The seller was represented by counsel and had acknowledged the covenants’ reasonableness. The Court of Appeal for Ontario still found the duration unreasonable, because it was tied to third-party consents and had no fixed outside limit. It said those facts “do not entirely immunize the clause from scrutiny”. Both the non-competition and the non-solicitation covenants were unenforceable, and the application judge’s finding that they could not be saved by “blue pencil” or “notional” severance was not disputed on appeal. Each of these results turned on its own facts, so treat them as illustrations of how a court reasons, not predictions.
The parts of a covenant to read
Martin v. ConCreate lists the factors for reasonableness: the geographic coverage, the period the covenant is in effect and the extent of the activity prohibited. Read each in your draft, and check who is bound.
- Activity: does the covenant bar only the business the buyer is buying, or more? In Martin, the Court of Appeal found a non-solicitation clause went beyond what was needed to protect the goodwill of the purchased business, because it was not limited to the businesses sold and reached products and services that came later.
- Territory: does it match where the business actually operated and where the parties expected it to operate?
- Duration: when does it start, and does it end on a fixed date or on an event someone else controls? Ask your lawyer what a court would make of an open-ended period.
- Who is bound: you personally, your holding company, family members or other owners? Ask whether each person signing understands the promise.
- Related terms: does the agreement separately restrict soliciting customers or staff, or using confidential information? Those are different promises, covered in non-compete versus non-solicit.
Ontario: a seller who becomes the buyer’s employee
This section applies to Ontario only. The Employment Standards Act, 2000 says no employer shall enter into an employment contract or other agreement with an employee that is, or includes, a non-compete agreement (s. 67.2(1)). Subsection 67.2(3) sets out an exception. It applies if there is a sale of a business or a part of a business, the purchaser and seller enter into an agreement as part of the sale that prohibits the seller from competing with the purchaser’s business after the sale, and, immediately following the sale, the seller becomes an employee of the purchaser. The section says “sale” includes a lease. If you are staying on as an employee, ask your lawyer how this applies to your agreement. The broader question is covered in how the non-compete ban applies when a business is sold.
Tax and the Competition Act
Section 56.4 of the federal Income Tax Act deals with amounts received or receivable for a restrictive covenant. Subsection 56.4(2) includes in a taxpayer’s income amounts in respect of the taxpayer’s restrictive covenant received or receivable by the taxpayer or by a taxpayer with whom the taxpayer does not deal at arm’s length, and subsection 56.4(3) sets out conditions under which that does not apply. Whether subsection (3) applies turns on its own conditions, so ask your accountant how it applies to your covenant before the wording is settled.
Section 45 of the Competition Act makes certain agreements between competitors an offence, and subsection 45(4) gives a defence where the person establishes, on a balance of probabilities, that the agreement is ancillary to a broader or separate agreement or arrangement that includes the same parties and is directly related to, and reasonably necessary for giving effect to, its objective, and where that broader agreement, considered alone, does not contravene the subsection. See whether a business-sale non-compete is illegal under the Competition Act.
Related reading
4 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Sources
Every requirement and figure referenced in this guide traces to a primary source. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Court of Appeal for OntarioCourt decisionMartin v. ConCreate USL Limited Partnership, 2013 ONCA 72
- 02Court of Appeal for OntarioCourt decisionMEDIchair LP v. DME Medequip Inc., 2016 ONCA 168
- 03Court of Appeal for OntarioCourt decisionMason v. Chem-Trend Limited Partnership, 2011 ONCA 344
- 04Government of OntarioGovernmentEmployment Standards Act, 2000, S.O. 2000, c. 41
- 05Government of Canada (Department of Justice)GovernmentIncome Tax Act, section 56.4 (restrictive covenants)
- 06Government of CanadaGovernmentCompetition Act
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.