Tax due diligence when buying a business in Canada
Tax due diligence asks where each federal tax exposure sits. In a share purchase, the company’s own tax history is what you check. In an asset purchase, ITA s.160 and ETA s.325 can make a transferee of property liable for some of the transferor’s amounts if the transferee is a spouse or common-law partner, a person under 18, or not dealing at arm’s length.
Once a letter of intent is signed, the tax question is no longer “does the business owe anything?” but “who would owe it after closing, and how would I find out first?” The answer depends on what you are buying. If you buy the shares of a corporation, the corporation’s own filings and accounts are what you check. If you buy assets, two federal provisions can reach a person who receives property in particular circumstances. This guide sets out those provisions in the Acts’ own terms and the checks that follow from them. It covers federal tax only.
In a share purchase, the company’s history comes with it
The CRA’s guidance for a change of owners or directors of a corporation is to update and validate the change with the federal or provincial incorporating authority and, once it shows on the corporate registry, send supporting documentation to the CRA to update business and owner information. Because the corporation itself is what you are checking, ask about every open year, every filing and every account balance. Do unpaid source deductions and HST follow a share purchase? covers that point on its own. The checks below are how to find exposure before the shares change hands, and the agreement is where you and your lawyer can allocate it.
In an asset purchase, read ITA s.160 and ETA s.325 closely
Section 160 of the Income Tax Act, subject to exceptions such as the one in subsection (4) for certain transfers to a separated spouse or common-law partner, applies where a person has transferred property, directly or indirectly, by means of a trust or by any other means whatever, to the person’s spouse or common-law partner (or a person who has since become one), to a person who was under 18 years of age, or to a person with whom the transferor was not dealing at arm’s length. In those cases, under paragraph (1)(e), the transferee and transferor are jointly and severally liable to pay an amount equal to the lesser of two amounts: the excess of the property’s fair market value over the fair market value of the consideration given, and the total the transferor is liable to pay under the Act in or in respect of the transfer year or any preceding year. The Minister may at any time assess a taxpayer for an amount payable because of the section. Section 325 of the Excise Tax Act is the GST/HST counterpart, with the same three categories of transferee, its own formula and its own exception for certain transfers to a separated spouse or common-law partner. In each section, subsection (5) can also deem a transferor not to be dealing at arm’s length with a transferee where the two did not deal at arm’s length at any time during a transaction or series of transactions and it is reasonable to conclude that one of its purposes was to avoid that joint liability. Both turn on the relationship between the parties and on what is given for the property, so ask whether you or anyone behind you could be a spouse or common-law partner, a person under 18, or someone not dealing at arm’s length with the seller, and what is paid for what is transferred.
Directors’ liability under ITA s.227.1 matters to a share buyer
Section 227.1 of the Income Tax Act makes the directors of a corporation at the time it was required to deduct, withhold, remit or pay jointly and severally liable with it for amounts it failed to deduct, withhold, remit or pay under the provisions the section lists, together with the interest or penalties relating to them. The section attaches that liability to a director, and it limits it: a director is not liable unless one of the collection or insolvency steps in subsection (2) has occurred, is not liable if the director exercised the degree of care, diligence and skill to prevent the failure that a reasonably prudent person would have exercised in comparable circumstances, and no action to recover the amount can be commenced more than two years after the director last ceased to be a director. For a share buyer the practical point is this: if you will become a director, the CRA warns of legal implications for outgoing and incoming directors and points to its circular on directors’ liability. Ask your lawyer how that applies to you.
Check each CRA account and the filing record
- Corporate income tax: the CRA says resident corporations (except tax-exempt Crown corporations, Hutterite colonies and registered charities) have to file a T2 return every tax year even if no tax is payable, so ask for each year’s return and notice of assessment and a gap list for any year not filed.
- Payroll: ask for proof that source deductions were remitted and the year-end information returns filed, and compare the CRA’s account statements with the payroll records.
- GST/HST: ask for the registration confirmation, the returns filed for each reporting period and the account statement, then reconcile reported sales to the books.
- Open matters: ask for any audit letters, objections or appeals, and for any arrangement to pay a balance over time.
- Seller relationships: ask whether the seller is, or could be, not dealing at arm’s length with you or anyone behind you, and whether anyone will receive property from the business before closing.
Compare the statements with the CRA’s own account balances rather than the seller’s summary, and ask for a fresh statement shortly before closing. How do I check for CRA debts before buying a business? walks through the program accounts.
How far back can a year be reopened?
A filed year is not necessarily closed. Under section 152(3.1) of the Income Tax Act, the normal reassessment period for a taxpayer that, at the end of the year, is a mutual fund trust or a corporation other than a Canadian-controlled private corporation is four years after the earlier of the original assessment notice and the original notification that no tax is payable. In any other case it is three years. The CRA notes that the period can be extended for various reasons. Ask which years are still within it, whether any waiver has been filed, and whether any reassessment is pending, and decide with your advisors how the agreement should deal with a year that could still be reopened.
Non-resident sellers and what this guide leaves out
If the seller may be a non-resident, special federal rules may apply to the purchase. Do I need a clearance certificate when buying from a non-resident seller? explains them, so ask about residence early. Provincial taxes and provincial payroll insurers are not covered here; check the rules and the issuing office where the business operates. The CRA also says a seller closing a GST/HST account must file a final return and remit any amount owing, so ask to see both.
Related reading
5 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Sources
Every requirement and figure referenced in this guide traces to a primary source. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Government of Canada (Department of Justice)GovernmentIncome Tax Act, section 160 (tax liability re property transferred not at arm’s length)
- 02Government of Canada (Department of Justice)GovernmentExcise Tax Act, section 325 (tax liability re transfers not at arm’s length)
- 03Government of Canada (Department of Justice)GovernmentIncome Tax Act, section 227.1 (liability of directors for failure to deduct or remit)
- 04Government of Canada (Department of Justice)GovernmentIncome Tax Act, section 152 (assessments)
- 05Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentChange of owners, partners, or directors
- 06Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentCorporation income tax return
- 07Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentClose your GST/HST account
- 08Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentWhen we reassess your T2 return
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.