Valuing a business that owns its premises
To value a business that owns its premises, ask how the business and the building are each to be assessed, because a business valuator and a property appraiser do different work. A business valuator weighs asset, income and market approaches, and a property appraiser assesses the real property.
Owning the building you operate from adds a second question to a sale: what is the business worth, and what is the property worth? This page does not value either. It sets out what the sources say about how value is assessed and what to ask your advisers, so that the right professional answers each question.
How a valuator may treat real property
Ontario valuation guidance describes three common approaches. An asset-based approach adds up the fair value of the business’s tangible and identifiable assets, which it lists as equipment, inventory, receivables and real property, and subtracts liabilities. An earnings-based approach values the income the business is expected to generate going forward, often starting from a normalized earnings figure. A market-based approach looks at what comparable businesses have sold for. The same guidance says most professional valuations blend more than one approach and use judgment to reconcile the results. BDC says a business valuator chooses a valuation method, or a combination of methods, depending on the type of business and the information available. Ask your valuator which approaches they will use, and why, for a business that owns its building.
Ask how the building will be assessed
The Appraisal Institute of Canada describes itself as a professional association for real property valuation in Canada, and says its members provide independent valuations that inform lenders, businesses and property owners. BDC notes that a commercial realtor can help with the parts of a sale that involve real estate holdings. Ask whether the valuator will rely on a separate property appraisal for the building, who would commission it, and whether the appraiser is a member of a recognized professional body. An estimated property value folded into an earnings-based figure is a question to put to your valuator, not an answer to accept.
Ask how occupancy cost is treated in the earnings
Ontario guidance describes a normalized earnings figure that adds back one-time expenses, the owner’s personal expenses run through the business, and above- or below-market owner compensation. Ask your accountant and valuator whether the earnings figure includes any charge for occupying the building, and how they propose to treat that cost when comparing the business with one that rents. Ask them to show each adjustment, so that you and the other side can see where you agree and where you do not.
Decide whether the property is part of the deal
Ask your lawyer and accountant whether the property would be sold with the business or kept by the seller and leased to the buyer, and to set out each structure, and how the price, the closing and the financing would work under each, before an asking price is set. Ask who would own the building afterward, and whether the lease terms, including rent and renewal, are written down before the sale price is agreed.
Ask lenders how each part would be financed
Ask a lender how it would treat the building and the operating business, and whether it would finance them together or separately. The Canada Small Business Financing Program guidelines provide for term loans to purchase real property of which the borrower is or will become the owner, subject to conditions including how much of the property the business itself uses and whether the borrower intends to sell or lease the operational area, and state that an individual or corporation that purchases real property for the sole purpose of rental is not an eligible borrower. If a seller keeps the building and leases it to the buyer, ask the lender and your lawyer how the program’s rules apply to each party. A buyer who needs financing for both should ask early whether one lender will handle both or two will be needed.
Tax and structure questions belong with your advisers
The Canada Revenue Agency says a person who realizes taxable capital gains from disposing of qualified small business corporation shares may be eligible to claim a capital gains deduction. Ontario guidance describes this lifetime capital gains exemption (LCGE) as letting an individual shelter some or all of a capital gain realized personally on a disposition of qualifying small business corporation shares, up to a lifetime limit. The same guidance says it applies only to shares that meet the QSBC tests, which include whether a sufficient proportion of the corporation’s assets are used in an active business carried on in Canada, both at the time of sale and over a preceding holding period. The guidance says these tests are fact-specific and depend on the corporation’s actual asset mix and history. Ask your accountant and lawyer whether a building held inside the operating corporation, in a separate company or personally affects whether the exemption can apply, and whether any restructuring needs to happen before a sale process starts.
- Ask the valuator which approaches they will use for the business, and how the building is treated
- Ask whether a separate property appraisal is needed, and who will commission it
- Ask the accountant how occupancy cost is treated in the normalized earnings
- Ask the lawyer to set out the structure options: sale with the building, or lease of the building
- Ask lenders early whether they will finance the building and the business together
- Ask the tax adviser how the way the building is held affects the sale, before terms are negotiated
Related reading
6 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Sources
Every requirement and figure referenced in this guide traces to a primary source. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Innovation, Science and Economic Development CanadaGovernmentCanada Small Business Financing Program — Guidelines
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Much Is a Small Business Worth? Valuation Basics for Ontario Buyers
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow the Lifetime Capital Gains Exemption Shapes the Asset vs Share Decision in Ontario
- 05Business Development Bank of CanadaIndustryHow to sell your business
- 06Appraisal Institute of CanadaIndustryAbout the Appraisal Institute of Canada
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.