What is an accounting practice worth?
What an accounting practice is worth is assessed by a valuator, who may use asset, earnings and market approaches in combination, depending on the practice and the transaction. No page can give a figure. Ask for client-level fee records, an aged receivables and work-in-progress schedule, and multi-year figures, and get an independent valuation.
No single number answers what an accounting practice is worth. The Business Development Bank of Canada (BDC) notes that a valuator may use one or more valuation methods, depending on the information available and the type of business and transaction. Ontario small-business guidance adds that two qualified valuators looking at the same financials can reasonably reach different figures, because valuation rests on judgment calls about which earnings to count, how much risk to attach to the future, and how comparable “similar” sales really are. This guide sets out how value is assessed and what to ask for, and it does not put a price on any practice.
The three approaches a valuator weighs
In Ontario, guidance on small-business valuation describes three common approaches, which professionals combine and weigh by the type of business. An asset-based approach adds up the fair value of tangible and identifiable assets, such as equipment, inventory and receivables, and subtracts liabilities. An earnings-based approach looks at the income the business is expected to generate, often starting from a normalized earnings figure that adds back one-time expenses, the owner’s personal expenses and above- or below-market owner compensation. A market-based approach looks at what comparable businesses have actually sold for, adjusted for size, industry, location and risk. Ask the valuator which approaches they used for your practice and why.
Why normalization is a place to look closely
Earnings-based approaches depend on how conservatively or optimistically the normalization adjustments are made, and the same Ontario guidance calls this a common area where seller and buyer disagree. For a practice, ask the seller to list each add-back separately, such as owner pay compared with what a replacement accountant would cost, and ask a buyer’s accountant to review them one at a time.
Client relationships and personal goodwill
Ontario guidance on goodwill describes it as the value of a business over and above its identifiable, separately valued assets. The Ontario valuation guidance warns that some of a business’s success may be tied to the current owner personally and may not transfer to a new owner at all, and that earnings depending heavily on one or two relationships are generally lower quality than diversified earnings. For an accounting practice, those become questions to put to the seller:
- Fees billed to each client for the last several years, with the length of each relationship
- Which clients deal only with the owner personally, and which also know other staff
- Whether any single client or small group accounts for a large share of fees
- Which engagements recur each year and which were one-off projects
- How many clients have left in recent years, and why
Earn-outs and holdbacks
The Ontario valuation guidance notes that holdbacks or earn-outs can bridge a genuine disagreement about value by tying part of the price to the business’s performance after closing, rather than forcing agreement on a single number up front. If client retention after the owner leaves is the open question, ask a lawyer whether part of the price should depend on it, and how retention would be measured.
Receivables and work-in-progress
Ontario guidance on goodwill lists receivables among a business’s identifiable, separately valued assets, apart from goodwill. Ask the seller for an aged receivables listing, showing what is owed by whom and for how long, and for a work-in-progress schedule that shows unbilled time by client. Ask how the contract will treat both items at closing, since how they are handled is a point to settle in writing with your lawyer and accountant.
Licensing for audit, review and compilation work
In Ontario, the Public Accounting Act, 2004 requires a person who practises public accounting to hold a public accounting licence (a professional corporation needs a certificate of authorization), subject to limited exceptions, and CPA Ontario regulates public accounting. Under the Act, public accounting means work done independently of the client that a third party can reasonably be expected to rely on: assurance engagements on financial statements, such as audits and reviews, and compilation engagements, unless the compilation carries the prescribed notice limiting any assurance to the accuracy of its computations. If the practice performs audit, review or compilation engagements, ask who holds the licence and whether that work, and the relationships attached to it, can move to a buyer, and get CPA Ontario’s answer in writing before relying on it. Outside Ontario, ask a lawyer or accountant in the practice’s province which licensing rules apply before relying on this.
Staff and dependence on the owner
Ask who actually performs the client work today. A staff list with each person’s role, tenure and client assignments shows how much work routes through the owner personally. Ask whether key staff have agreed to stay after the sale, and whether any of them are likely to leave with clients.
Seasonality and the figures you review
Ask whether the practice’s billing and collections rise and fall with the tax-filing calendar, and do not rely on a single month’s figures. Ask for monthly revenue and collections for at least several years, and have an accountant restate them on a consistent basis before anyone compares them with an offer.
Why informal rules of thumb need care
If you come across an informal claim about what practices sell for as a multiple of fees, treat it as unverified: ask where it came from, what deal facts sat behind it, and whether those facts match the practice in front of you. A valuator working from the practice’s own records is the safer route to a figure, and a human professional should confirm any number before a price is set.
Related reading
6 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Sources
Every requirement and figure referenced in this guide traces to a primary source. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Much Is a Small Business Worth? Valuation Basics for Ontario Buyers
- 03Treadstone AssociatesAdvisoryAccounting Automation
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Goodwill Is Taxed When You Sell a Business in Ontario
- 05Canadian Federation of Independent BusinessResearch dataCapital Gains Changes
- 06Chartered Professional Accountants of CanadaIndustryBridging to public accounting registration (licensure) after certification
- 07Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernmentBusiness valuation: What’s your company worth?
- 08Government of Ontario (e-Laws)GovernmentPublic Accounting Act, 2004
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.