What is an insurance brokerage worth?
There is no standard figure for an insurance brokerage. A valuator chooses among asset, earnings and market approaches, according to BDC, and this guide sets out what to ask about the book of business, carrier agreements and trust account. This guide covers Ontario; check the rules where you operate.
This guide does not put a number on any brokerage. It sets out how sources say value is assessed and what to ask for, and it covers Ontario, where general insurance brokerages are licensed by the Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (RIBO). If your brokerage operates elsewhere, check the rules where you are.
How a valuator approaches it
BDC says a valuator chooses an appropriate valuation method, or combination of methods, depending on the type of business and the information available. It describes earnings-based methods as looking at forecasted earnings or cash flow and past results, market-based methods as applying a multiple that may be based on EBITDA, revenue or other metrics, and asset-based methods as typically used where value is asset-related rather than operations-related. BDC adds that the most suitable combination depends on the purpose of the valuation and the company’s characteristics.
Ask a valuator which approach they used for the brokerage and why, which earnings figure they started from, and whether the book of business was examined separately. An Ontario valuation guide describes the income approach as often starting from a “normalized” earnings figure that adds back one-time expenses, personal expenses run through the business and above- or below-market owner compensation, so ask for the add-backs and the document behind each.
Examine the book of business directly
Ask for the book broken down by client, by line of insurance and by carrier, with the renewal history for each: how many policies renewed at their last cycle, how many were lost, and why. Request the underlying detail rather than a summary of income alone, and confirm it reconciles to the financial statements.
Commission, contingent and profit-sharing income
Ask for income reported in separate lines: commission on placed premium, and any contingent or profit-sharing payment from a carrier. For each contingent payment, ask the carrier or the brokerage what it depends on and request the payment history over several years, so that you know which amounts are recorded as recurring and on what basis.
Carrier agreements
Read every carrier agency agreement for provisions about a change of ownership or control, including any notice or consent requirement and any right to reassess or end the relationship. An Ontario article on assignable contracts says that in an asset sale each contract generally has to be assigned to the buyer, usually with the other party’s consent, and that in a share sale most contracts continue unless they contain an express change-of-control clause requiring notice or consent. Ask each carrier early, and in writing, what it requires, and ask your lawyer whether any consent should be a closing condition in the purchase agreement.
Client concentration
An Ontario article on customer concentration says that if a major customer relationship was built on trust in an individual rather than the business, it may not survive a change of ownership, and that buyers may ask for specific representations about key customer relationships, an earn-out tied to a concentrated customer, or a holdback. Ask for the largest accounts by premium and by commission, and how long each has been with the brokerage.
Producers and the founder
Ask which clients are managed by which licensed producer, and whether account histories are documented in the brokerage’s own systems. Ask whether any producer or the founder is expected to stay after a sale, for how long, and what is agreed in writing. If a large share of the book is serviced by one person, ask what the plan is for those relationships if that person leaves.
Licence, trust account and compliance record
RIBO says it licenses insurance brokerages in Ontario, that a firm must appoint a Level 3 unrestricted licensed individual as Principal Broker to manage the firm and ensure it follows the Registered Insurance Brokers Act, regulations and by-laws, and that all firms must have a trust account to obtain and maintain their registration. On the sale of a brokerage, RIBO says the transition of commissions should be agreed in the purchase and sale agreement and that the brokerage must be trust positive at all times, including before and after the sale. It recommends consulting qualified specialists, especially legal and accounting, about a sale or acquisition. Ask for the licence status, the trust account records and any complaint or claims history, including the brokerage’s errors-and-omissions coverage.
Getting an independent valuation
BDC says it can be helpful to hire a business valuator for a realistic picture of what a business is worth, and that a valuator’s figure is a guideline for approaching negotiations. Ask for a report that shows the method, the earnings figure and how the book of business was examined, so that you can check each against the documents above.
Related reading
6 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Sources
Every requirement and figure referenced in this guide traces to a primary source. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Much Is a Small Business Worth? Valuation Basics for Ontario Buyers
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryAre Your Contracts Assignable?
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryCustomer Concentration Risk: Why It Can Sink an Ontario Business Sale
- 05Canadian Federation of Independent BusinessResearch dataSuccession Tsunami: Preparing for a decade of small business transitions
- 06Registered Insurance Brokers of OntarioRegulatorBrokerage Licences
- 07Registered Insurance Brokers of OntarioRegulatorSale of Brokerage, Brokerage Perpetuation and the Regulations
- 08Business Development Bank of CanadaIndustryHow to sell your business
- 09Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernmentBusiness valuation: What’s your company worth?
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.