Deavo
LegalGuide · 4 min read

When a seller breaches a non-compete after closing

Start with the covenant’s exact words and dated evidence of the activity. In Ontario, a court can grant an interlocutory injunction and award damages, and the purchase agreement may add an indemnity or holdback. A litigation lawyer should assess the facts.

A buyer who thinks the seller has started competing, and a seller who has been accused of it, face the same first questions. What exactly does the covenant say, and what can anyone show? This guide covers what to gather, what an Ontario court has the power to order, what the purchase agreement itself may provide, and what one Court of Appeal decision shows. It does not predict how any dispute would turn out. That depends on the wording, the facts and the evidence, and it is a question for a litigation lawyer in your province. For what a seller agrees to at closing in the first place, see what post-closing covenants bind a seller.

Start with the exact words

A non-compete is a term of a contract, so read the clause itself, not a summary or a memory of what was negotiated. Note who is bound, the seller personally or only the selling company. Note the activity covered, the start date and length, the area, and any defined terms. In Martin v. ConCreate, 2013 ONCA 72, the Court of Appeal for Ontario said that if a covenant is ambiguous, in the sense that what is prohibited is not clear as to activity, time, or geography, it is not possible to demonstrate that it is reasonable, and it is therefore unreasonable and unenforceable. Whether your clause is clear is a question for a lawyer reading your document. Pull the rest of the agreement too: the definitions, the notice clause and any dispute clause.

Gather evidence of the activity

A concern is not the same as proof. Whoever you are in this dispute, collect facts and dates before anyone writes to the other side. Keep originals, note when and how you found each item, and do not alter or delete anything.

  • The signed agreement, any amending documents, and the closing date, so the covenant’s start and end can be worked out.
  • Dated copies of anything public: a website, social media posts, advertising, a new listing or a business-name or incorporation record. Ask your lawyer which searches to run.
  • What the seller is actually doing: a new location, a new customer, a new service, with dates and how you learned of it.
  • Any approach to former customers or staff, written down with names, dates and the source of your information.
  • The correspondence between the parties since closing, including anything that could read as consent or a waiver. A seller should keep the same record.

A demand letter is a step to discuss with a lawyer

A letter to the other side setting out the concern is something to discuss with a lawyer before anything is filed. Whether to send one, when, and what it should say depend on the facts and on what the agreement says about notice and disputes. A seller who receives such a letter should take it to a lawyer promptly. Ask the lawyer, too, how any time limits apply to your situation.

What an Ontario court can order

This section covers Ontario court procedure only. If the agreement or the business is governed by another province’s law, check the rules where you are. Under the Courts of Justice Act, s.101(1), in the Superior Court of Justice an interlocutory injunction may be granted where it appears to a judge of the court to be just or convenient to do so. An interlocutory injunction is an order made before the case is finally decided. Separately, s.99 says a court that has jurisdiction to grant an injunction may award damages in addition to, or in substitution for, the injunction. Whether either remedy would be available on your facts is for a litigation lawyer to assess.

What the purchase agreement may provide

The agreement may give a contractual route before, or alongside, court. Check whether your agreement has an indemnity for breach of the seller’s covenants, and what it says about how a claim is made. BDC’s guidance on negotiating a purchase agreement describes the indemnity section as setting the compensation the vendor will pay if disclosures turn out to be inaccurate or covenants are not respected, and describes a buyer holding back part of the price as security so that funds are available if there is a claim against the vendor. So check whether your agreement has a holdback, whether it allows the buyer to set off a claim against money still owing, and what it says about releasing a holdback while a dispute is open. Check also for a clause on where and how disputes are decided, and any clause on remedies. A seller should read the same clauses, since money still owed to you may be affected. See also whether a radius restriction stops you opening nearby.

What MEDIchair shows

MEDIchair LP v. DME Medequip Inc., 2016 ONCA 168, concerned a franchise agreement, not a sale of a business. The franchisor, MEDIchair, applied to enforce a restrictive covenant against its former franchisee and related parties, and the Court of Appeal records that it was successful on that application. The Court of Appeal then allowed the appeal, set aside the judgment and dismissed the application. It said the covenant was not ambiguous and its time and territory were not unreasonably broad. But it held the covenant unreasonable as between these two parties in the circumstances, because MEDIchair had no legitimate or proprietary interest to protect within the covenant’s territory. The decision also recites that where a restrictive covenant is negotiated as part of the sale of a business, courts apply a presumption of validity. The result turned on its facts. It is an example of what a court looked at, not a forecast for your clause.

Sources

Every requirement and figure referenced in this guide traces to a primary source. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.

  1. 01
    Government of OntarioGovernment
    Courts of Justice Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.43
    ontario.ca·Checked Oct 20, 2026
  2. 02
    Court of Appeal for OntarioCourt decision
    MEDIchair LP v. DME Medequip Inc., 2016 ONCA 168
    ontariocourts.ca·Checked Nov 4, 2026
  3. 03
    Court of Appeal for OntarioCourt decision
    Martin v. ConCreate USL Limited Partnership, 2013 ONCA 72
    ontariocourts.ca·Checked Nov 4, 2026
  4. 04
    Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernment
    Major pitfalls to avoid when negotiating a purchase agreement
    bdc.ca·Checked Oct 21, 2026

Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.