Can a section 85 election be amended after it is filed?
Yes, but only with the Minister’s permission. Subsection 85(7.1) of the Income Tax Act lets the Minister permit an election to be amended if, in the Minister’s opinion, it would be just and equitable. It is a discretion, not a right, and a penalty applies. CRA Information Circular 76-19 says an election filed under section 85 cannot be revoked.
Once a section 85 election is filed, paragraph 85(1)(a) of the Income Tax Act deems the agreed amount to be the taxpayer’s proceeds of disposition and the corporation’s cost, subject to the other paragraphs of subsection 85(1). If the amount turns out to be wrong, subsection 85(7.1) is the provision that deals with amending the election. This page covers that route and what the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) says about it. For what the election does in the first place, see what a section 85 rollover is.
What the Act allows
Subsection 85(7.1) applies where, in the opinion of the Minister, the circumstances of a case make it just and equitable to permit an election under subsection 85(1) or 85(2) to be amended. The amended election is then deemed made on the day the original was required to be made, if it is in prescribed form and an estimate of the penalty is paid with it. The words that matter are “in the opinion of the Minister”. Nobody can file an amendment as of right. In Information Circular 76-19, the CRA also says an election can be amended but not revoked.
What the CRA says it will accept
The circular says the CRA will generally accept an amended election if its purpose is to revise an agreed amount and, without the revision, there would be unintended tax consequences. Its examples include correcting an inaccurate property valuation. It also says the CRA will not permit revisions where, in its view, the main purpose is retroactive tax planning, such as using losses or tax credits nobody considered when the election was filed. It accepts an amendment only where a valid election was originally filed. The circular is an older publication, so ask your accountant whether the CRA still applies it as written.
The penalty
Subsection 85(8) sets the penalty for an amended election at the lesser of two amounts, one of which is built on the number of months, or parts of months, between the original deadline and the amended election. Under subsection 85(9), the Minister assesses the penalty and any balance is payable to the Receiver General. Your accountant can estimate it for your facts.
Price adjustment clauses
The circular says a price adjustment clause does not amend a section 85 election automatically. To give effect to one, you have to file an amended election under subsection 85(7.1). For how the CRA treats a value that it disputes, see what happens if the CRA disagrees with the value.
What to ask
- What exactly is wrong in the filed form T2057, and what unintended result does it cause?
- Was a valid election filed in the first place?
- Who will request the amendment, and who calculates the penalty estimate to pay with it?
Related reading
4 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Government of Canada — Justice LawsGovernmentIncome Tax Act, section 85 (transfer of property to a corporation by a shareholder)
- 02Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentTransfer of Property to a Corporation Under Section 85
- 03Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentT2057 Election on Disposition of Property by a Taxpayer to a Taxable Canadian Corporation
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.