How do I check a business for hidden debt?
To check a business for hidden debt, ask your lawyer which searches for registered security and court judgments against the seller and the company apply where it operates (in Ontario, a Personal Property Security Act search and an execution search), ask about CRA debts separately, compare the balance sheet with the loan statements and contracts, and ask for protections in the purchase agreement.
In Ontario, an article on execution searches notes that not every debt a seller owes shows up on a balance sheet. Ask the seller for the loan statements, lease agreements and supplier terms behind each figure, and ask your accountant to compare them with the balance sheet instead of accepting the listed liabilities as complete. Several points below rest on Ontario sources, so they are written for Ontario. Ask your lawyer which searches and rules apply where the business operates.
Search for security registered against the business
Under Ontario’s Personal Property Security Act, section 43, on request and payment of the required fee the registrar issues a certificate stating whether a financing statement or financing change statement is registered in which the name searched is shown as a debtor. Ask your lawyer to run this search against the business’s correct legal name, and against the seller’s name if the seller is an individual, and to explain each registration found.
Search for court judgments
In Ontario, a judgment is a court’s formal decision that one party owes another party money, or must do something. In Ontario, once a creditor has one, it can take further steps to enforce it, commonly by filing the judgment for execution against the debtor’s property through the local enforcement office. In Ontario, an execution or judgment search checks whether any such enforcement filings exist against the seller, or against the target corporation itself, in the relevant jurisdiction.
In Ontario, a clean execution search at one point in time is not the end of the story, because a new judgment can be entered against the seller between the day you search and the day you close. Ask your lawyer whether to repeat the search close to closing.
Ask about CRA debts separately
In Ontario, an article on execution searches says an execution search does not typically cover debts owed to the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA), because tax debts and their enforcement mechanisms are handled separately from ordinary civil judgments. The same Ontario article says that if CRA debt is a concern, it calls for its own line of due diligence.
In Ontario, an article on CRA debts says a business can look financially healthy on paper and still owe the CRA money, for example unremitted source deductions, unpaid GST/HST or reassessed corporate tax from a prior year. The same Ontario article adds that Canadian tax law includes rules that can, in certain circumstances, make a person who receives property from someone who owes tax debts responsible for that debt, up to the value of what they received, particularly where the transfer is not at arm’s length or is not for full value. Ask your lawyer how those rules apply to your deal.
Ask the seller for confirmation of any active CRA audit, reassessment or payment arrangement. In Ontario, formal mechanisms exist in some circumstances for confirming a taxpayer’s standing with the CRA, but they are specific and fact-dependent, so ask your lawyer whether one is available to you.
Check how the deal structure changes the exposure
- In Ontario, in a share purchase any judgment against the corporation is a debt of the entity you are acquiring.
- In Ontario, in an asset purchase a judgment against the seller personally, or against the seller corporation generally, does not automatically transfer to the specific assets you are buying, but it is still worth knowing about.
- In Ontario, an arm’s-length asset purchase at fair value is generally a lower-risk position than inheriting a corporation’s full tax history, but related-party transfers and below-value sales can still raise exposure.
Ask for protections in the purchase agreement
In Ontario, an article on execution searches lists protections that can follow a finding: a representation and warranty from the seller confirming there are no outstanding, unsatisfied judgments against the seller or the corporation, current as of closing; an indemnity covering any judgment that existed but was not disclosed; and a closing condition requiring any disclosed judgment to be satisfied, or specifically addressed through a holdback, before the deal completes. In Ontario, an article on CRA debts adds seller representations and indemnities addressing pre-closing tax liabilities, and a holdback, especially in a share deal.
In Ontario, an article on indemnity baskets and caps says a claim has to clear the basket and stay within the cap to be fully recovered, and that recovery is pursued from the holdback or escrow first, if one exists, before the seller is chased directly for any remaining amount within the cap. Before you agree to that language, ask your lawyer whether, if a real problem surfaced tomorrow, it would produce a meaningful recovery.
Related reading
14 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Due diligence
Buying
Financing
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryExecution and Judgment Searches Before Buying a Business in Ontario
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryChecking for Outstanding CRA Debts Before Buying a Business in Ontario
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryIndemnity Baskets and Caps in an Ontario Business Sale
- 05Government of OntarioGovernmentPersonal Property Security Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.10
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.