How do I spot a membership community that depends on one star member?
Count how much of the posts, replies, referrals and event hosting traces back to one person. If removing that person from the numbers changes the picture sharply, the community depends on them, and you should ask what keeps them there after a sale.
Dependence rarely shows in the headline numbers. Ask the seller for activity data broken down by member, after asking your lawyer whether any of it can be shared, then remove the most active person and look at what remains. Do the same for replies, since a community where one person answers most questions is leaning on them heavily.
Look at how new members arrive. If many say they came because of one person’s content or recommendation, that person is part of the acquisition engine. Ask whether renewals fall when that person is quiet, for example during a holiday or an illness.
Read recent threads and notice whose name the others address. A star member often becomes the informal moderator, and members may expect them to settle disagreements. Then ask the hard questions, calmly and early. Is the person paid, and under what written arrangement? Do they know about the sale? Would they stay under a new owner, and is that commitment written down? Ask your lawyer how to document any ongoing arrangement. Finally, check whether a second person could do part of the star’s job if they left, and how long it would take to prepare them.
Key takeaways
- Remove the top member from the activity numbers and see what is left.
- Check whether new joiners and renewals follow that person’s presence.
- Get any commitment to stay in writing, reviewed by your lawyer.
- Check whether a second person could do part of the star member’s job.
Related reading
12 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Buying
- Expert answerHow do I check a membership site’s member activity and engagement?
- Expert answerHow do I find out if a repair garage depends on one star technician?
- Expert answerDoes one star plumber carry the customer relationships at this plumbing company?
- Expert answerHow can I tell if a cybersecurity consultancy relies on one star consultant?
- Expert answerWhat do a food truck’s regular lunch spots depend on?
Due diligence
- Expert answerHow do I tell if a sushi spot’s lunch rush depends on one nearby office?
- Expert answerHow do I spot a food counter that relies on one delivery app for orders?
- Expert answerHow do I check how many CrossFit box members come only for one coach’s class?
- Expert answerDo a men’s grooming lounge’s straight razor services depend on one senior barber?
- Expert answerHow can I tell if an accounting firm’s work depends on one senior partner’s relationships?
- Expert answerHow can I tell if a commercial cleaning firm depends on one building manager’s goodwill?
- Expert answerHow can I tell if a motel depends on one contractor or work crew for its bookings?
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernmentHow to conduct due diligence when buying a business
- 02Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernmentWhat are the steps to buying a business?
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.