How do I tell if a shoe store’s returns of worn shoes are eating into margin?
Ask for the return log for a full year and follow each returned pair: was it sent back to the supplier, marked down as a worn pair or written off? The margin loss sits in the pairs that cannot be sold again.
Returns rarely show up as one line in the accounts, so you have to build the picture yourself. Ask what the shop does with a pair that comes back after being worn outdoors. Some go back to the supplier as defects, some go to a clearance rack marked as worn, and some are simply written off. Each path affects margin differently.
Compare the return log with sales by season and by brand. A spike after a particular style may point to a fit or quality problem, not a policy problem. If one supplier will take defective pairs back and another will not, the shop carries the cost of the second one.
Then ask about the policy itself. Is it written, posted and applied the same way by every staff member? Loose enforcement is a common source of loss. A new owner can tighten it, but should ask how regular shoppers would react. Your accountant can help you work out what returns actually cost the shop. Ask also for a sample of the notes staff make when they accept a return. Those notes often show the reason in plain words, such as fit, comfort or quality, and they point to what the shop could fix without touching the policy at all.
Key takeaways
- Follow each returned pair to its outcome: sent back to the supplier, marked down or written off.
- Compare returns by brand and season to find the pattern.
- Check whether the return policy is written and applied consistently.
Related reading
15 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Due diligence
- Expert answerHow do I check a kitchenware store’s online store and shipping returns?
- Expert answerHow can I tell if a shoe store’s aged inventory is hiding in the stockroom?
- Expert answerHow do I check how a kitchenware store tracks knives, cookware and appliance brands by margin?
- Expert answerWhat should I ask about a lingerie boutique’s size inventory and returns of worn items?
- Expert answerHow can I check how a medical supply store handles returns on sanitary products?
- Expert answerHow do I check how a sporting goods store handles returns and defective gear?
- Expert answerHow can I tell if a kids clothing store’s customers return as the children outgrow sizes?
- Expert answerHow can I tell if a roll-former’s rollers and dies are worn?
- Expert answerWhat should I check about sizing returns in an online shoe store?
Buying
- Expert answerHow do I judge an outdoor outfitter’s footwear fitting expertise and returns?
- Expert answerHow do I tell if an art supply store’s student discount programme is eroding margins?
- Expert answerHow do I tell if a shoe repair shop’s leather goods and bag repairs are growing?
- Expert answerHow do I check a shoe store’s sizes and stock depth by season?
- Expert answerWhich accessory sales matter most to a barbecue store’s margins?
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernmentWhat is the operating profit margin?
- 02Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernmentHow to conduct due diligence when buying a business
- 03Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernmentWhat is inventory
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.