Deavo
ValuationExpert answer · 1 min read

Is a franchise worth more than an independent business?

Value turns on the specific business, not the label: an Ontario law firm’s article says valuation turns on judgment calls about which earnings to count, how much risk to attach and how comparable other sales are, and describes asset, earnings and market approaches. Ask for a valuation of the specific business, with its royalties and the franchise agreement’s terms shown.

This is a valuation question, separate from whether you should choose a franchise or an independent business for lifestyle or risk-tolerance reasons. It is about how the value of either is assessed, and what to request so the comparison is on the same footing.

How value is assessed

In Ontario, a law firm’s article on small business valuation describes three common approaches: asset-based, which adds up the fair value of the assets and subtracts liabilities; earnings-based, which often starts from a normalized earnings figure; and market-based. It adds that valuation is not a precise science, that two qualified valuators can reasonably arrive at different figures, and that most professional valuations blend more than one approach.

What to ask for on a franchise

A franchise is run under an agreement with a franchisor, so the figures behind any valuation should show what that agreement costs and how long it runs. Ask the seller for the financial statements with royalties and any other payments to the franchisor shown as separate lines, and for the franchise agreement itself.

Where to look when comparing the two

  • What the franchise agreement requires you to pay the franchisor, and how those payments appear in the financial statements
  • How much term and renewal remains on the agreement
  • How the earnings figure was normalized, including any one-time or owner-related expenses added back
  • Whether the territory, lease and the current owner’s role are described in the documents you were given
  • Whether the franchisor’s consent to a transfer is required, and on what conditions

Why a single answer is misleading

Treating “franchise” and “independent” as two fixed categories hides the details that a valuator works from. The Ontario article above says valuation depends on judgment calls about which earnings to count, how much risk to attach to the business’s future and how comparable other sales really are, so the useful step is a valuation of the specific business, not a category comparison.

Sources

This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.

  1. 01
    Canada Revenue AgencyGovernment
    Selling a business
    canada.ca·Checked Aug 14, 2026
  2. 02
    Treadstone LawLegal commentary
    How Much Is a Small Business Worth? Valuation Basics for Ontario Buyers
    treadstonelaw.ca·Checked Aug 14, 2026
  3. 03
    Treadstone LawLegal commentary
    Buying an Existing Franchise Resale in Ontario (Arthur Wishart Act)
    treadstonelaw.ca·Checked Aug 14, 2026
  4. 04
    Canadian Franchise AssociationIndustry
    What is a Franchise?
    cfa.ca·Checked Oct 22, 2026

Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.