Should I buy a franchise or an independent business?
Neither option is inherently better; a franchise resale adds a franchisor and its agreement. In Ontario, almost every franchise agreement requires the franchisor’s consent before an outlet is transferred, so a resale involves that agreement and that approval, while an independent business has no franchisor, so you ask the seller what systems exist and what is documented.
Buying an existing franchise location and buying an independent business both mean acquiring an operating business. A franchise resale adds the franchise agreement and the franchisor’s role in the transfer, so check those documents before you negotiate a price with the seller.
What a franchise resale adds to the process
In Ontario, almost every franchise agreement requires the franchisor’s consent before an outlet is transferred, and that approval runs on its own timeline and criteria, separate from what you and the seller negotiate. Read the franchise agreement for its transfer clause and ask the franchisor what it reviews (in Ontario this usually includes financial information, business experience and sometimes an interview), whether training is required, and whether the lease is held by the franchisor or needs the landlord’s consent. Also review the agreement for royalty structure, territory rights, and any renewal or transfer fees before you finalize a price with the outgoing franchisee.
Support and structure versus control
Ask the franchisor, in writing, what brand, system, marketing and supplier arrangements come with the location and what they cost. For an independent business, ask the seller which systems exist, who built them, and what is documented, since you will be maintaining them yourself and no franchisor stands behind them. Ask what you would control in each case, such as pricing, branding and suppliers, and what the franchise agreement restricts.
Due diligence differs by structure
- For a franchise, review the current franchise agreement and ask about any history of disputes between the franchisor and other franchisees, and ask your lawyer whether you are entitled to a disclosure document — in Ontario, whether a resale triggers one under the Arthur Wishart Act depends on the facts of the deal.
- For an independent business, ask how much depends on the seller’s personal relationships and informal systems, since there is no franchisor documentation to refer to.
- In both cases, confirm the lease, financials, and any liabilities the same way you would for any acquisition.
Ongoing costs and obligations
Ask for every recurring franchise charge in the agreement, such as the ongoing royalties that the Canadian Franchise Association says franchisees typically pay, and include them in your financing and offer calculations the same way you would any other fixed cost. For an independent business, ask the seller what knowledge the owner holds that is not written down, and what handover period they will provide.
Related reading
15 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Legal
Buying
- Expert answerDoes buying a franchise resale require retraining?
- ComparisonBuying a business vs starting one
- ComparisonBuying a franchise vs an independent business
- Expert answerHow long does it take to buy a fast food franchise resale?
- Expert answerFranchise restaurant or independent restaurant: what should a buyer weigh?
- GuideBuying a franchised auto repair shop in Canada
- DefinitionBusiness format franchise
Selling
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryBuying an Existing Franchise Resale in Ontario (Arthur Wishart Act)
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryFranchisor Consent to Transfer
- 04Canadian Federation of Independent BusinessResearch dataSuccession Tsunami: Preparing for a decade of small business transitions
- 05Government of OntarioGovernmentArthur Wishart Act (Franchise Disclosure), 2000, S.O. 2000, c. 3
- 06Canadian Franchise AssociationIndustryWhat is a Franchise?
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.