Buying a business vs starting one
Buying an existing business means paying a purchase price and, in a share purchase, taking on its contracts and known and unknown liabilities, while starting one means no purchase price but start-up and operating capital, according to an Ontario legal article. Ask lenders how each is financed.
Buying an existing business and starting one from scratch are both ways to become an owner, but the legal, financial and risk profile of each is different. This page sets out what a cited Ontario source says about the two paths and lists what to ask a lender, a lawyer and an accountant before choosing. It does not tell you which path is right for you.
What buying an existing business involves
An Ontario legal article on the two paths says that what comes with the business depends heavily on how the deal is structured. In a share purchase, the corporation itself changes hands, and its contracts, licences and its known and unknown liabilities come with it, addressed, imperfectly, through representations, warranties and indemnities in the purchase agreement. In an asset purchase, the buyer and seller choose the specific assets to transfer and the specific liabilities, if any, to assume. The same article says that thorough due diligence, covering financial statements, contracts, leases, employee records, licences, litigation history and tax compliance, is what protects a buyer from inheriting problems they did not bargain for.
A purchase price may include goodwill on top of the hard assets; an Ontario legal article describes goodwill as the gap between what a business’s tangible assets are worth on their own and what a buyer is willing to pay for the whole operating business. Ask the seller and your accountant how much of the asking price is goodwill and how much is equipment or inventory.
- Request historical financial statements and ask your accountant to review them.
- Ask which contracts, leases and licences the business holds and whether each can be assigned to you.
- Due diligence is how you find what the previous owner left undocumented or unresolved.
- Ask whether the deal is an asset purchase or a share purchase, and which liabilities you would assume.
What starting one from scratch involves
The same Ontario article describes a start-up as needing start-up and operating capital but no purchase price, and as carrying no inherited liabilities from a prior owner. A start-up has no financial history of its own, so ask a lender what it would want to see in place of one before you plan around a loan. If you are comparing the two paths, put the same questions to each: how much cash is needed up front, how long until the business supports you, and what happens if early revenue is slower than planned.
How financing is approached
The Business Development Bank of Canada (BDC) lists a Business Purchase or Transfer Loan among its business loans, with the tagline “Pave the way for a smooth acquisition.” The federal Canada Small Business Financing Program shares risk with lenders on loans to small businesses, but whether it covers a given acquisition is a question for your lender. Ask each lender what it would finance, what security and personal guarantees it would want, and what documents it needs.
If you are buying, ask the seller whether they would consider vendor financing. Ask your accountant and lawyer about buying with no cash of your own and whether registered savings can be used to fund a business you would control. If you are a first-time buyer, ask each lender which documents to bring to the first meeting.
What you take on the day you close
Ask how much the business depends on the departing owner or on one person who holds the client relationships; this is key-person risk. Ask for a transition plan in writing. On staff, Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, section 9, applies when a business is sold as a going concern and the purchaser hires the seller’s employee within 13 weeks of the sale or of the employee’s last day, whichever comes first. In that case the employee’s employment is deemed not to have been terminated or severed by the sale for purposes of the Act. The section does not apply to every sale automatically, so ask your lawyer how it applies to your deal. This describes Ontario only; check the rules in the province where the business operates.
Ask about these points directly. A structured due diligence process and a direct list of questions for the seller are meant to surface them before an offer becomes binding.
Questions to ask yourself
Neither path is right for everyone, and this page does not say which fits you. CFIB’s succession research reports that finding a buyer or suitable successor is the most cited succession challenge among small business owners and that acquisitions remain an underutilized pathway into entrepreneurship.
- How much cash can you put in, and what could a lender or the seller add to it?
- Do you want to manage an existing team and customer relationships, or build them yourself? Ask whether a lack of industry experience matters for the business you are looking at.
- Is there a specific business for sale that matches your plan, or an idea no listing represents?
- How long can you go before the business has to support you?
Paths between buying and starting
Another route is a franchise resale. In Ontario, franchise transfers and resales are treated separately from an ordinary business sale under the Arthur Wishart Act (Franchise Disclosure), 2000 and under the terms of the franchise agreement itself, and the agreement may require the franchisor’s consent before an outlet can be transferred. Ask for the franchise agreement and ask the franchisor what its approval process involves. Whether this beats buying or starting independently is its own comparison. Ask your lender and lawyer whether a franchise transfer could involve a vendor take-back.
Buying does not have to mean buying alone. Read buying with a partner versus buying alone, and ask a lawyer to put the ownership split, each person’s role and what happens if one partner wants out into writing before closing. You can also read about buying out an existing partner, a management buyout and, for a professional practice, an associate buy-in. Whether the deal includes the real estate the business operates from is a separate decision: see leasing versus owning your premises.
Building the team, whichever way you go
Ask whether you need a lawyer; the answer is set out in do I need a lawyer to buy a business. If you work with a broker, ask who they act for and how they are paid, and read about a separate buy-side advisor and buy-side versus sell-side representation. Other advisers, such as an accountant, a financing contact lined up early and a valuator, depend on the deal; a checklist helps you plan which to engage.
Where you look, and where you buy
See finding a business to buy for where to look. Ask a lawyer in the province where the business operates which employment standards apply there and how a corporation’s good standing is confirmed. The guides for Ontario, Quebec (and civil law and business sales in Quebec), Alberta, British Columbia, Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Nova Scotia and New Brunswick go into each of those provinces.
Guides for specific kinds of business
If you are weighing a particular kind of business, read its own guide before comparing paths. Ask the seller and the relevant regulator which licences, permits or approvals the business holds and whether they transfer to you.
- Buying a brewery or brewpub in Canada
- Buying a cannabis cultivation facility in Canada
- Buying a banquet hall and event venue in Canada
- Buying a bar and pub in Canada
- Buying a bowling centre in Canada
- Buying a beef cow-calf operation in Canada
- Buying a berry farm in Canada
- Buying a broiler poultry farm in Canada
- Buying a cash crop farm in Canada
- Buying a bed and breakfast in Canada
- Buying a campground and RV park in Canada
- Buying a car wash in Canada
- Buying a bookkeeping firm in Canada
- Buying a cabinetry and millwork shop in Canada
- Buying a café or coffee shop in Canada
- Buying a B2B e-commerce store in Canada
- The AI business buyer checklist
- The auto repair business buyer checklist
Related reading
6 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Buying
- ComparisonBuying a franchise vs an independent business
- Expert answerShould I buy a franchise or an independent business?
- ComparisonSelf-funded search vs a funded search fund
- Expert answerHow do I learn about buying a small business, and where do I start?
- ComparisonBuying a business vs investing in stocks or real estate
Sources
This comparison is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Innovation, Science and Economic Development CanadaGovernmentCanada Small Business Financing Program
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryBuying an Existing Business vs Starting One in Ontario
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryA First-Time Business Buyer's Guide to Buying in Ontario
- 05Treadstone LawLegal commentaryFinancing Options for First-Time Business Buyers in Ontario
- 06Treadstone LawLegal commentaryCSBFP Loans for Buying a Business — Ontario
- 07Treadstone LawLegal commentaryWhat is vendor take-back financing in an Ontario business sale?
- 08Business Development Bank of CanadaIndustryBusiness Purchase or Transfer Loan
- 09Treadstone LawLegal commentaryEvaluating Goodwill When Buying a Business
- 10Treadstone LawLegal commentaryCash Needed to Buy a Small Business in Ontario
- 11Treadstone LawLegal commentaryRed Flags When Buying a Small Business in Ontario
- 12Treadstone LawLegal commentaryKey-Person Dependency
- 13Treadstone LawLegal commentaryESA Section 9 and Continuity of Employment on an Ontario Business Sale
- 14Treadstone LawLegal commentaryBuying a Business With No Industry Experience — Ontario
- 15Treadstone LawLegal commentaryBuying a Business With a Partner in Ontario
- 16Treadstone LawLegal commentaryManagement Buyout Guide for Ontario Employees
- 17Treadstone LawLegal commentaryFranchisor Consent to Transfer
- 18Treadstone AssociatesAdvisoryProfessional Practice Owners
- 19Canadian Federation of Independent BusinessResearch dataSuccession Tsunami: Preparing for a decade of small business transitions
- 20Statistics CanadaResearch dataBusiness Dynamics measures, by industry, per province or territory
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.