Comparisons
Two options, one decision
Side-by-side comparisons of the choices Canadian buyers and sellers actually face — asset versus share, broker versus direct, and the rest.
Brokers
- Business broker vs M&A advisorA business broker and an M&A advisor both help an owner sell, but they are described differently. In Ontario, advisors are said to handle larger or more complex deals and brokers broader marketing. Ask each how they are paid.
- Online marketplace vs broker listingAn online marketplace gives a business visibility to a wide pool of self-directed buyers, usually without actively marketing, screening or negotiating on the seller’s behalf, while a broker listing adds a professional running that process — confidential marketing, buyer screening, negotiation — often by placing the same listing on one or more marketplaces as part of the work.
- Buy-side vs sell-side representationOn this page, sell-side means acting for the seller and buy-side means acting for the buyer. In Ontario, a sell-side broker or advisor is engaged by the seller under a listing agreement to market the business and negotiate for the seller; a buyer should ask any advisor to confirm in writing that they act for the buyer, and what they will do, such as finding, evaluating or negotiating for a target.
- Retainer vs success feeIn Ontario, a retainer is a fee paid at the start of the engagement, before any sale, while a success fee is a percentage of the final sale price paid mainly when the sale closes. Ask whether the retainer is credited against the success fee.
- Using a broker vs selling it yourselfSelling yourself means no broker commission is owed, but BDC notes that brokers have a process for reaching and vetting buyers, so ask who would do that work while you run the business. A broker can approach buyers discreetly on your behalf, for a fee. In Ontario, no fixed schedule or regulation sets broker fees, so ask how a broker is paid and have a lawyer review any listing agreement.
- Exclusive vs open listingIn Ontario, an exclusive listing gives one broker the sole right to market and sell your business for the term of the agreement, while a non-exclusive (open) listing lets you work with more than one broker, or find a buyer yourself, without owing the listing broker a commission for that outcome.
Buying
- Owner-operator vs absentee ownershipCompare owner-operator and absentee ownership by asking the seller who runs the business day to day and what depends on the owner personally. In Ontario, one law article lists signs of owner dependence, so ask each lender how its view changes if you will not be running the business.
- Buying a competitor vs entering a new marketBuying a competitor consolidates an existing market and can raise customer-overlap and, at real scale, competition-law considerations, while entering a new market through acquisition diversifies the business but hands the buyer an operation, customers and staff it does not yet understand.
- Buying a single-location vs a multi-location businessAsk for each site’s own lease and financial statements, and who runs each site day to day. In Ontario, almost every commercial lease requires the landlord’s consent before it can be assigned to a new tenant, so every lease needs checking.
- Buying the business vs buying the real estateAsk whether the premises are part of the deal and on what terms. If you buy only the business, ask for the lease; in Ontario, almost every commercial lease requires the landlord’s consent before assignment. If you also buy the property, ask your lawyer which property checks apply.
- Main street vs lower middle marketA main street business is typically small enough for a single owner-operator to run personally, priced and financed accordingly, while a lower middle market business is typically large enough to be run by a professional management team, with more formal financials, a more institutional financing process and a more involved legal deal structure.
- Buying a profitable business vs a turnaroundWhether the business you are weighing is profitable or struggling, ask your accountant and lawyer to check its financial statements, any debts owed to the CRA and its liabilities. In Ontario, the articles cited below list what to look at on each; ask your accountant and lawyer how they apply to your deal.
- Buying a service business vs a product businessWhatever the business sells, ask for revenue by customer, the receivables, any inventory and equipment records, and the contracts that may need consent. Ontario sources on each of these are cited below; ask your lawyer about your province.
- Keeping vs replacing the management teamKeeping the existing management team means depending on people the buyer did not hire, and in Ontario a written retention agreement is one of the main tools used to keep key people. Replacing it gives the buyer its own team but raises employment-law, recruiting and transition questions to plan before closing.
- Self-funded search vs a funded search fundWhether you plan to pay your own search costs or investors offer to back the search, ask who pays costs during the search, who has a say in what is bought and who owns what after closing, and have a lawyer review any investor agreement before you sign it.
- Refinancing vs assuming existing business debtAsk the existing lender in writing whether the buyer can take over the loan and on what terms, and ask the buyer’s lender what it needs to finance a new loan instead. In Ontario, how a lender secures the loan differs between an asset purchase and a share purchase.
- Buying a business vs starting oneBuying an existing business means paying a purchase price and, in a share purchase, taking on its contracts and known and unknown liabilities, while starting one means no purchase price but start-up and operating capital, according to an Ontario legal article. Ask lenders how each is financed.
- Buying a franchise vs an independent businessIn Ontario, buying a franchise instead of an independent business adds a franchisor to the deal, and the franchise agreement usually requires the franchisor’s consent to a transfer and may set a transfer fee. For an independent business, ask the seller for the records and contracts that show how it runs.
- Earn-out vs royalty paymentsAn earn-out makes part of the sale proceeds depend on the business’s future results. A royalty is a continuing payment for the right to use property such as a brand or system. Income Tax Act s.12(1)(g) can reach payments that depend on use of property, so ask an accountant.
- Buying a business vs investing in stocks or real estateBuying an operating business means acquiring a going operation after your own due diligence and a negotiated purchase agreement. Holding stocks or rental property is a different kind of ownership, regulated and taxed differently. This page compares features, not returns.
Due diligence
- Quality of earnings vs auditA quality of earnings report analyzes and normalizes a business’s historical earnings specifically for a transaction and carries no auditor’s opinion, while an audit is a formal assurance engagement performed to recognized auditing standards that results in an independent opinion on the financial statements — the two are not interchangeable, and a QoE is not a form of audit.
- Closing adjustments vs the post-closing true-upIn an Ontario sale, what reaches the seller on closing day is the price less any holdback and any secured debt paid out, and a working capital adjustment can be calculated after closing. Ask your lawyer which figures are final on closing day and which are not.
- Due diligence vs warranty protectionBDC says due diligence helps the buyer evaluate the advantages and risks, and can even make a buyer walk away. In Ontario, the seller’s representations and warranties can be qualified by a disclosure schedule, and indemnity claims limited by a negotiated basket and cap. Ask your lawyer how the two interact.
Financing
- Seasonal vs year-round businessAsk for monthly results, not only annual totals. For a seasonal business, ask how the seller covered the months with less revenue and what a lender would require. The federal Canada Small Business Financing Program lists a line of credit among its financing options.
- BDC vs chartered bank financingBDC describes itself as Canada’s bank for entrepreneurs and says it complements the role of other banks. Its Business Purchase or Transfer Loan page says a financing structure may combine your own investment, a business loan and seller financing. Ask each lender what it requires.
- Term loan vs line of creditA term loan advances a lump sum upfront on a fixed repayment schedule and is normally what actually funds the purchase price, while a line of credit is a revolving facility a business draws against and repays repeatedly, used to manage day-to-day working capital rather than to buy the business in the first place.
- Equipment financing vs a general term loanEquipment financing is secured specifically against the machinery or vehicles it pays for, with repayment usually matched to that equipment’s useful life, while a general acquisition term loan is typically secured by a blanket claim over the whole business and funds the purchase price as one number, without tying repayment to any single asset.
- Private lender vs bank financingThe cited sources describe bank and institutional lending, not private lenders, so ask any private lender who it is, whether it is registered or regulated, and what it requires. BDC says banks usually prefer secured loans backed by assets like inventory, real estate and equipment.
- Bringing in an equity partner vs debt financingBDC says equity financing raises capital by selling investors an ownership stake, and the money does not have to be repaid. Loan financing must be repaid, with the cost of borrowing usually in the form of interest, within a predetermined timeframe, and does not involve selling an interest in the company.
- Asset-based lending vs cash-flow lendingAsk each lender whether it sizes a loan against specific collateral or against the business’s cash flow, and what security, reporting and covenants it requires. BDC says the debt service coverage ratio is calculated by dividing EBITDA by principal and interest.
- Bank loan vs vendor financingIn Ontario, a vendor take-back has the seller finance part of the purchase price instead of collecting it all in cash at closing, while a bank or BDC acquisition loan is typically secured against the target business’s assets. In Ontario, a BDC loan is often used alongside a vendor take-back.
- CSBFP-backed vs conventional lendingThe Canada Small Business Financing Program has the federal government share a lender’s risk on a qualifying loan to an eligible small business, which typically makes financing more attainable on a smaller down payment, while conventional lending is the bank’s own money at the bank’s own risk appetite, without a government eligibility test to satisfy first.
- Commercial mortgage vs business acquisition loanA commercial mortgage is a loan secured by a commercial property, so it is tied to the real estate. A business acquisition loan is lent against the business, with the senior lender holding a first charge against assets such as receivables, inventory, equipment and real estate. A purchase that includes the building can involve both.
- Business loan vs personal loan or home equity line of credit to buy a businessA business loan is made against the business and its assets, while a personal loan or home equity line of credit is borrowed in the buyer’s own name, with a HELOC secured by the buyer’s home. A business loan can still reach personal assets through a guarantee.
Legal
- Lawyer vs notary in a Quebec business dealA Quebec lawyer represents your interests and can represent you in court. A notary must act impartially and take account of everyone involved, and cannot represent clients in court when a matter is contested. Éducaloi says a notary is required to sign a mortgage on real property.
- Buying a business with a partner vs aloneWhether you buy alone or with a partner, ask each lender who it would require to sign. In Ontario, a law firm says a lender financing a purchase often wants more than the buyer’s signature, and a fellow shareholder may be asked to co-sign or guarantee. Ask your lawyer to put any partner agreement in writing before closing.
- Vendor take-back vs earn-outBDC describes vendor financing, also called a vendor take-back or VTB, as acquisition debt that holds back part of the purchase price as a debt to the vendor. If an agreement uses an earn-out, ask your lawyer to explain in writing how the amount is worked out.
- LOI vs term sheetBefore signing either, ask your lawyer which clauses bind. BDC says a letter of intent is not intended to be fully binding unless it says so, but can bind on confidentiality and exclusivity. Ask your lawyer how a document called a term sheet differs.
- Letter of intent vs purchase agreementBDC describes a letter of intent as a document that sets out the main terms of a proposed deal to direct the negotiation of the final terms, and says it is not intended to be fully binding unless it expressly says so. Ask your lawyer which clauses of the letter and of the purchase agreement bind you.
- Deposit vs escrowIn Ontario, escrow typically means funds held by a neutral third party under a separate escrow agreement that spells out the conditions for release. In Ontario, what happens to a deposit if a closing condition fails depends entirely on how the purchase agreement allocates it, so ask your lawyer to put both in writing.
- Representations and warranties vs indemnitiesRepresentations and warranties are the seller’s contractual statements of fact about the business, while an indemnity is the separate promise to pay if one of those statements — or a specific named risk identified during diligence — turns out to be wrong or actually happens, and a deal can lean heavily on either one without the other doing very much work at all.
- Non-compete vs non-solicitIn a business sale, Ontario sources describe a non-compete as barring the seller from competing with the purchaser’s business, and a non-solicit as barring the seller from actively pursuing the clients, customers or others it names. Ontario courts have generally shown more willingness to enforce reasonable sale-of-business non-competes than employment ones. Even those must be reasonable.
- Earn-out vs holdbackAn earn-out pays the seller additional money after closing, calculated from how the business actually performs once the buyer owns it, while a holdback sets aside part of the price already agreed on at closing to cover claims the buyer might later bring against the seller — one is contingent upside, the other is contingent security.
- Share purchase agreement vs shareholders’ agreementA share purchase agreement is the contract that moves existing shares from sellers to a buyer. A shareholders’ agreement is the continuing contract among the owners. Under the CBCA, a buyer of shares subject to a unanimous shareholder agreement is deemed a party to it.
- Share purchase agreement vs subscription agreementA share purchase agreement transfers existing shares from their holders to a buyer. A subscription is the other route in: the corporation issues new shares, so the company, not a selling owner, is the counterparty, and the CBCA sets rules on who may be issued shares and how they are paid for.
- One-way vs mutual confidentiality agreementA one-way agreement binds only the party receiving information; a mutual one binds both sides. BDC describes the duty of a receiving party and says the agreement can protect both parties’ information. PIPEDA s.7.2 describes an agreement that binds the recipient before a deal and each party after it closes.
- Non-compete vs NDA in a business saleAn NDA restrains the use or disclosure of confidential information, and operates from the negotiations. A non-compete restrains the seller from competing, and is a restrictive covenant with its own tax treatment. A sale can carry one, the other or both.
- Franchise disclosure document vs franchise agreementThe disclosure document is the information package a franchisor gives before signing. The franchise agreement is the contract governing the relationship, and the package must include copies of the proposed agreements. Ontario, BC and Alberta each regulate this by their own Act.
- Business loan agreement vs promissory noteA promissory note is a signed, unconditional promise to pay a sum of money. A business loan agreement is the wider contract that sets the loan’s terms, including covenants and what counts as default. Security and guarantees can be separate documents.
Selling
- Blind listing vs named listingIn Ontario, blind marketing describes a business in general terms without naming it, so only vetted buyers learn who the seller is. Ask your broker or lawyer what a named listing would make public and what your plan is if word leaks.
- Auction process vs negotiated saleWhether to approach many buyers or negotiate with one is a question to put to your broker. BDC says brokers and investment bankers have a process for reaching out to a very broad number of acquirers, vetting them and following a timeline for them to express their interest. Ask your broker which route fits.
- Sale-leaseback vs selling the real estate with the businessAsk your lawyer to lay out, in writing, how a sale-leaseback and a sale of the real estate together with the business would each work for your property, then ask a commercial realtor, an appraiser and your accountant to review each.
- Full sale vs partial saleA full sale transfers all of the seller’s ownership at once and ends their financial stake and decision rights in the business, while a partial sale has the seller keep a minority or majority stake and usually stay involved as a co-owner alongside the buyer, trading some immediate liquidity for continued upside and, often, an ongoing say in how the business is run.
- Selling to a strategic vs a financial buyerOne pro of selling to a strategic buyer is price: BDC says a strategic buyer is often willing to pay more because it sees synergies. On the other side, ask whether it plans to fold your business into its own operation, and what that means for your staff and brand.
- Selling a franchise vs selling an independent businessAn independent sale runs between owner and buyer plus third parties such as a landlord or lender. A franchise sale adds the franchisor’s agreement and, where a province has franchise legislation, its rules. The federal tax steps apply to both.
Succession
- Management buyout vs third-party saleA management buyout sells the business to the people already running it, typically financed against the business’s own track record and negotiated quietly with a buyer who already knows the operation, while a third-party sale takes the business to the open market, which usually tests the price against more buyers but takes longer and requires broader confidentiality management.
- Passing the business to family vs selling itCFIB’s Small Business Succession in Canada page says most owners expect to transfer their business outside the family, and that family succession remains common as well. In Ontario, a family sale still needs a real purchase agreement and independent legal advice for each side.
- Winding up vs selling the businessFor a federally incorporated corporation, winding up means discharging its liabilities and distributing or disposing of its property before it is dissolved, while selling transfers the operating business to a new owner. In a sale, the agreement may set an amount attributed to goodwill, which an Ontario article on goodwill defines as value over and above the identifiable assets.
- Family trust vs direct share transfer for business successionA family trust holds the shares for beneficiaries and, under section 104(4), is deemed to dispose of its capital property on listed days, including 21 years after dates the Act sets; a direct transfer to children can engage the non-arm’s length rules, section 84.1 and section 160 joint liability.
Tax
- Share sale vs hybrid saleA share sale transfers the whole corporation as one unit, while a hybrid sale layers an asset-level carve-out, or a pre-closing reorganization, onto a share sale so specific assets, liabilities or licences move differently from the rest of the company — reached for when neither a clean share sale nor a clean asset sale can satisfy something material to one side of the deal.
- Asset sale vs share saleAn asset sale transfers the individual assets and liabilities a buyer agrees to take, sold out of the seller’s corporation, while a share sale transfers ownership of the corporation itself, including everything already inside it. The two produce different tax results for the seller and different liability exposure for the buyer, which is why the structure is negotiated rather than simply chosen by whoever is selling.
- GST/HST on selling business assets vs selling real propertyUnder the Excise Tax Act, a registrant’s sale of business assets and its sale of real property can both be taxable supplies, but they differ on who collects, on exempt residential sales, and on how the section 167 business-sale election applies.
- Lifetime capital gains exemption on small business shares vs farm or fishing propertyThe capital gains deduction applies to two classes: shares that meet the small business corporation tests, and farm or fishing property used by the owner or close family. The ownership and use tests differ for each.
Valuation
- Accountant vs business valuatorAn accountant helps prepare financial statements, projections and the tax structure of a sale, while BDC says a business valuator can give a realistic picture of what the business is worth, choosing a valuation method that fits the business. Ask each what they will and will not deliver.
- Business valuation vs real estate appraisalA business valuation looks at the operating business, and a real estate appraisal looks at the land and building. They are prepared by different professionals, so when a business owns its premises ask whether the valuation covers the property and whether a separate appraisal is needed.
- Working capital peg vs cash-free debt-freeA cash-free, debt-free structure is the market convention that the seller keeps the cash on the balance sheet and clears the debt before closing, while a working capital peg is a separately negotiated target for the operating assets — receivables, inventory and payables — that has to remain in the business, and the first does not automatically protect a buyer against the second being stripped down before closing.
- SDE vs EBITDAThe two figures restate reported profit in different ways, and they can treat the owner’s pay differently, so before setting a number on one basis against a number on the other, ask how each was built. BDC notes that EBITDA includes salaries, so ask the seller or broker how a listing’s figure treats pay and what was added back.
- Leasing vs owning your premises, when you sellIf you lease your premises, only the business itself is for sale and the lease has to be assigned or renewed for the buyer to take over, while if you own the real estate, you can bundle the property into the sale, sell it separately, or lease it back to the buyer — each option changes the price, the financing and who the buyer has to satisfy to close.
- A multiple-based estimate vs a formal appraisalA multiple-based estimate applies a multiple to a measure of earnings, such as EBITDA, while a formal valuation is a report a valuator prepares from the specific business’s records. BDC describes three report types, from a basic calculation to a comprehensive report, so ask which one you need and why.
- Business value vs annual revenueAnnual revenue is the income a business reports from its sales. Business value is the economic value a valuation arrives at, which BDC says can draw on earnings-based, market-based or asset-based methods. Revenue can be one input, but it is not the value.
- Business valuation vs sale priceA valuation is a valuator’s estimate of what a business is worth, generally given as a range. The sale price is the amount the buyer and seller actually agree, and BDC says it is often different, influenced by factors such as the seller’s eagerness to sell and the buyer’s strategic interests.
- Goodwill vs other intangible assetsGoodwill is an intangible asset that is not individually identified, while other intangibles, such as licences or trademarks, are identifiable. They differ in accounting treatment and impairment and, for tax, may fall in a different CRA capital cost allowance class.
- EBITDA multiple vs P/E ratioAn EBITDA multiple divides a business’s value by earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization. A P/E ratio divides a common share’s price by earnings per common share. A private business has no market share price, so a P/E-type figure can enter through listed-company comparables.
- EBITDA multiple vs capitalization rateAn EBITDA multiple is a ratio of value to earnings, drawn from market pricing of comparable businesses. A capitalization rate is a divisor applied to a normalized single period of earnings and is built from risk factors. This page is about business earnings, not real-estate cap rates.
- EBITDA multiple vs discounted cash flowAn EBITDA multiple applies a market-derived multiple to earnings. Discounted cash flow takes the present value of expected cash flows using a discount rate. BDC says DCF is used when cash flow is expected to fluctuate substantially.
- Revenue multiple vs EBITDA multipleA revenue multiple applies to sales, the top line. An EBITDA multiple applies to earnings after operating expenses but before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization. BDC says a valuation multiple may be based on either, or on other metrics.