Passing the business to family vs selling it
CFIB’s Small Business Succession in Canada page says most owners expect to transfer their business outside the family, and that family succession remains common as well. In Ontario, a family sale still needs a real purchase agreement and independent legal advice for each side.
CFIB’s Small Business Succession in Canada page says most owners expect to transfer their business outside the family, naming sales to an unrelated buyer and to employees, and that family succession remains common as well, through a family sale or a family transfer. It also says finding a buyer or suitable successor is the most cited succession challenge, followed by a lack of time to plan and difficulties determining the value of the business.
Passing the business to family
In Ontario, an article on buying a business from a family member says a family deal still involves a real transfer of assets or shares, real tax consequences and, often, other family members with an interest in seeing the deal handled fairly. The same Ontario article says a family sale is structured the same two ways as any other Ontario business sale, a share sale or an asset sale, and that a gift of a business or its shares is a different transaction from a sale, with its own tax consequences.
- In Ontario, the article says a family deal needs a real purchase agreement, a real price and documentation of what is being transferred and on what terms; ask your lawyer to prepare them
- In Ontario, it lists independent legal advice for each side, and tax and accounting advice for both sides, among the things a family sale still needs
- In Ontario, it says that if siblings or other relatives were told they would have a role or a share in the business, you should get clear before closing on whether that expectation is being addressed
- In Ontario, it says that if the retiring relative stays involved after the sale, the scope, duration and any compensation should be put in writing
- Ask your accountant what the tax consequences would be of a gift, a sale and a sale below market value in your situation
Ask the owner whether any processes or decisions exist only in their head, and ask for them in writing.
Selling on the open market
The CRA’s Selling a business page says that if you are selling your business or part of it, you generally set an amount for the entire business, and that in some cases the sales agreement sets out a price for each asset, a value for the inventory and, if applicable, an amount attributed to goodwill. It also says you may be able to jointly elect with the purchaser to have no GST/HST payable on the sale if the conditions on that page apply; the election cannot be made if you sell only one or more assets of your business, or if you are a registrant and the purchaser is not.
- The CRA page says that if the business has employees you must close your payroll account, and that if it has a GST/HST account you must contact your tax services office to close it
- It says to contact your tax services office whenever an owner of a sole proprietorship, a member of a partnership or a member of a corporation’s board of directors changes
- It says that if you realized taxable capital gains from qualified farm or fishing property or qualified small business corporation shares, you may be eligible to claim a capital gains deduction
- In Ontario, an article on the lifetime capital gains exemption says it shelters a gain an individual realizes on selling qualifying shares personally, and does not apply directly to a corporation’s own sale of its assets
How to choose
CFIB’s page says succession planning remains limited, and that owners with a formal written succession plan are far more confident in achieving a successful exit. Ask a family member directly whether they want to run the business, and ask yourself how much time you have to plan before you need to act.
In Ontario, the lifetime capital gains exemption article says the exemption depends on the shares and the corporation qualifying, not on who the buyer is, but that sales to related parties can raise other tax and valuation issues worth flagging to your accountant. Ask your accountant to compare, for your own corporation, a family transfer with a sale to an outside buyer, and ask your lawyer what each would require in writing.
Related reading
13 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Succession
- DefinitionSuccession plan
- Expert answerHow do I value a business for a family transfer?
- ComparisonWinding up vs selling the business
- ComparisonManagement buyout vs third-party sale
- GuideHow does succession work for a family business in Canada?
- ComparisonFamily trust vs direct share transfer for business succession
- Expert answerHow do I transfer my business to the next generation?
- DefinitionIntergenerational business transfer
- Expert answerCan I switch to family succession after planning an outside sale?
- Expert answerHow does a buy-sell agreement work in a family business?
Sources
This comparison is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Canadian Federation of Independent BusinessResearch dataSuccession Tsunami: Preparing for a decade of small business transitions
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryBuying a Business From a Family Member in Ontario
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow the Lifetime Capital Gains Exemption Shapes the Asset vs Share Decision in Ontario
- 05Treadstone AssociatesAdvisoryFamily Business & Succession — preparing to sell, transition or hand over
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.