Winding up vs selling the business
For a federally incorporated corporation, winding up means discharging its liabilities and distributing or disposing of its property before it is dissolved, while selling transfers the operating business to a new owner. In a sale, the agreement may set an amount attributed to goodwill, which an Ontario article on goodwill defines as value over and above the identifiable assets.
Not every owner has a buyer waiting, and some plan to close instead. CFIB’s succession research found that most owners expect to transfer their business outside the family, while some expect to close altogether, which puts jobs, services and economic activity at risk. The two paths work differently, and the right questions differ for each.
Winding up
This section looks at closing the business instead of handing over an operating one. For a federally incorporated corporation, Corporations Canada says it can be dissolved only when its property has been distributed and its liabilities discharged; on the route that starts with a certificate of intent to dissolve, it notifies creditors and, for example, collects its property, disposes of property not distributed in kind, discharges its obligations and distributes the remaining property among its shareholders. Ask an accountant what a wind-up, dissolution and final distribution to shareholders would mean for tax in your corporation, and ask a lawyer which dissolution rules apply to it.
- Ask which assets can be sold individually and which are tied to leases or contracts that need a third party’s consent
- Ask the accountant what tax applies to disposing of each asset and to distributing the proceeds
- Ask the lawyer what must be settled with creditors, employees and landlords before the corporation is dissolved
- Ask whether any buyer has shown interest in the whole business before committing to a wind-up
Selling the business
Selling passes the business to a new owner. The CRA notes that a sales agreement may set a price for each asset, a value for inventory and, where it applies, an amount attributed to goodwill. An Ontario article on goodwill defines it as the value of a business over and above its identifiable, separately valued assets, and says that in an asset sale whatever is left of the agreed price after the identified assets is typically allocated to goodwill.
- Ask your lawyer and broker, or your accountant if you sell without a broker, for a realistic view of the timeline for your business; an Ontario article on how long a sale takes lists phases such as marketing and buyer outreach and the buyer’s due diligence
- Get financial statements and corporate records organized, since the same article says incomplete records are a common source of delay
- Ask an accountant how asset-sale and share-sale proceeds would be taxed, since an Ontario article on goodwill says the choice between an asset sale and a share sale changes how the value attributed to goodwill is taxed
- Ask what the CRA requires on closing accounts if you sell: it says you might have to cancel your business number, and you must close your payroll account if you have employees
How to choose
Instead of assuming one path wins, test your own facts with the people who advise you. Ask a broker or advisor whether buyers could be interested in the customer relationships, staff and lease as they stand, and how much of the business depends on you personally. Ask your accountant to compare the tax result of each path for your corporation. Ask your lawyer what obligations to staff, landlords and creditors each path triggers. Set a date by which you will decide, so an unsuccessful search for a buyer does not quietly run on.
Related reading
6 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Succession
Sources
This comparison is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Long Does It Take to Sell a Business in Ontario?
- 03Canadian Federation of Independent BusinessResearch dataSuccession Tsunami: Preparing for a decade of small business transitions
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Goodwill Is Taxed When You Sell a Business in Ontario
- 05Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada (Corporations Canada)GovernmentGuide on dissolving a business corporation
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.