A multiple-based estimate vs a formal appraisal
A multiple-based estimate applies a multiple to a measure of earnings, such as EBITDA, while a formal valuation is a report a valuator prepares from the specific business’s records. BDC describes three report types, from a basic calculation to a comprehensive report, so ask which one you need and why.
An owner who wants a sense of what a business might fetch will meet two tools with a similar goal. A multiple-based estimate takes a measure of earnings and applies a multiple to it. A formal valuation is a report prepared by a business valuator from the specific business’s records. This page sets the two side by side and lists what to ask. It does not give a multiple or a value for any business.
A multiple-based estimate
A multiple-based estimate starts from an earnings figure, such as earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA), and applies a multiple to it. BDC notes that the specific multiple used varies greatly based on the industry, market conditions and other factors. The figure it produces is only as good as the earnings figure and the multiple behind it, so ask where each came from. In Ontario, a published legal guide on valuations before a sale cautions against any rule-of-thumb multiple offered without underlying analysis, and says a generic multiple applied to revenue or profit is not a substitute for a proper valuation.
- Ask which earnings figure was used and how it was adjusted
- Ask where the multiple came from, and which sales it was drawn from
- Ask what the estimate leaves out, such as customer concentration, the lease and how much the business depends on its owner
- Ask who prepared it and what their credentials are
A formal valuation
BDC notes that a business valuator can prepare three types of reports, ranging from basic to highly detailed. In ascending order, they are a calculation, which is a brief report providing basic details following a minimal review and little or no corroboration of information; an estimate, which is a moderately detailed report based on limited review, analysis and corroboration; and a comprehensive report, which is a highly detailed report based on a comprehensive, corroborated review and analysis. BDC also notes that the valuator chooses an appropriate valuation method, or combination of methods, depending on the type of business and the information available.
- Ask which of the three report types is being offered, and what it will and will not cover
- Ask which records the valuator will review, and which methods they expect to use
- Ask about the valuator’s credentials and their experience with businesses of a similar size and industry
- Ask for the fee and the timeline before engaging them
How to choose
Ask your accountant, your lawyer and the valuator which one you need before you pay for anything: what the number is for, who will rely on it, what they will want to see behind it, and whether a lender, a co-owner, a tax authority or a court is likely to ask for a particular kind of report. BDC says a valuator’s report can also help you evaluate buyers’ offers and bolster your position in negotiating the price or terms.
If you start with a multiple-based estimate, treat it as a prompt for questions rather than a figure to quote to buyers. Ask the valuator or your accountant what a fuller report would add, and what it would cost in fees and time. Keep a written record of what each person you consulted told you and what information they were given.
Related reading
6 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Sources
This comparison is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Much Is a Small Business Worth? Valuation Basics for Ontario Buyers
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryGetting a Business Valuation Before You List
- 04Business Development Bank of CanadaIndustryHow to sell your business
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.