Vendor take-back vs earn-out
BDC describes vendor financing, also called a vendor take-back or VTB, as acquisition debt that holds back part of the purchase price as a debt to the vendor. If an agreement uses an earn-out, ask your lawyer to explain in writing how the amount is worked out.
BDC names vendor financing and an earn-out together as ways a seller can remain involved with the company after a sale. This page keeps the two apart. It sets out what BDC says about vendor financing, what an Ontario source says about securing a vendor take-back, and the questions to put to your lawyer and accountant about an earn-out and about the tax on payments that arrive after closing.
Vendor take-back
BDC’s article on vendor financing says vendor financing, also known as vendor take-back or VTB, is a form of business acquisition debt that allows a buyer to hold back a portion of the purchase price as a debt to the vendor. It adds that vendor financing is often part of an acquisition financing package that also includes the buyer’s own investment, a bank loan and mezzanine financing, and that its payment terms are usually less rigid than traditional bank financing, which can mean no payments for several months or interest-only payments for a set period.
- BDC says that in almost all cases vendor financing is considered a junior debt and subordinate to bank loans and other financing, a point the buyer will want to make sure the seller understands from the outset
- BDC’s article says to bring vendor financing up as early in the negotiations as possible, ideally in the initial offer
- In Ontario, a vendor take-back without security is really just an unsecured loan: if the buyer stops paying, the seller’s only recourse is a lawsuit for the debt, with no direct claim against any specific asset
- In Ontario, for an asset sale, registering under the Ontario Personal Property Security Act is the standard way to secure a vendor take-back against the buyer’s equipment, inventory and other personal property
- In Ontario, other lenders’ registrations against the same assets can rank ahead of or alongside the seller’s, depending on timing and any priority agreements, so a seller taking security should search under that Act against the buyer and the assets before closing
- In Ontario, an unregistered vendor take-back agreement can still be valid and enforceable as a contract between the seller and the buyer, but registration is what gives the security priority protection against other creditors and later purchasers
Earn-out
None of the sources cited on this page defines an earn-out or says how one is documented or secured, so if an offer or letter of intent uses the word, ask your lawyer to explain in writing what it means in that document. Questions worth putting to your lawyer include the following.
- What is measured, over what period, and who prepares the figures?
- What may the seller see while the earn-out runs, and how would a disagreement over the figures be resolved?
- Does the agreement limit how the buyer runs the business after closing, and if so, how?
- Is any amount payable if the stated measure is not met, and what happens to the earn-out if the business later changes hands?
- Is the earn-out secured, and if so against what, and how would that security rank against any lender’s?
Tax on payments received after closing
CRA’s page on selling a business lists topics to review, including the business number, payroll, GST/HST, change of ownership and the value of inventory and other assets. It also says that a seller who realized taxable capital gains from the disposition of qualified farm or fishing property or qualified small business corporation shares may be eligible to claim a capital gains deduction. CRA also publishes form T2017, Summary of Reserves on Dispositions of Capital Property, which individuals use to claim a reserve on dispositions of capital property in the year or to report a reserve claimed on the previous return.
Ask your accountant, before anything is signed, whether a reserve applies to the take-back, how payments under an earn-out would be reported and in which year. The earn-out and when tax is payable on money not yet received is an article on this question; read it with your accountant rather than relying on it alone.
Questions to settle before signing
Whichever mechanism is on the table, ask your lawyer to explain in writing how it is documented, whether and how it is secured, what triggers each payment and what happens if a payment is missed. Where a vendor take-back sits alongside a bank loan, ask how the priority between the seller’s security and the bank’s will be documented. BDC’s article says the team for a deal like this should include lawyers, accountants, financial advisors and your banking partners.
Related reading
13 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Financing
- DefinitionVendor take-back (VTB)
- Expert answerHow do the due date and a balloon payment work in a vendor take-back note?
- Expert answerCan a vendor take-back note convert into equity if I default?
- GuideVendor take-back financing, explained
- GuideVendor financing and seller financing: how a vendor take-back works
Tax
Legal
Sources
This comparison is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Sellers Secure a Vendor Take-Back Loan in an Ontario Business Sale
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryEscrow and Holdbacks in an Ontario Business Sale
- 04Business Development Bank of CanadaIndustryHow to sell your business
- 05Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernmentVendor financing (VTB) for mergers and acquisitions
- 06Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentHow does a seller claim the capital gains reserve on a vendor take-back?
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.