Keeping vs replacing the management team
Keeping the existing management team means depending on people the buyer did not hire, and in Ontario a written retention agreement is one of the main tools used to keep key people. Replacing it gives the buyer its own team but raises employment-law, recruiting and transition questions to plan before closing.
Once a sale closes, the buyer has to decide what to do with the managers who ran the business before. Keeping them means depending on people the buyer did not hire. Replacing them means the buyer chooses its own team but takes on employment-law, recruiting and transition questions. The employment rules below come from Ontario sources; if the business is elsewhere, ask an employment lawyer which rules apply in your province.
Keeping the existing management team
In Ontario, a law-firm article says key employees can be a flight risk during a sale, and that a key employee retention agreement is one of the main tools sellers, and sometimes buyers, use to keep critical people in place through the transition. Ask each manager you want to keep whether they will stay, and ask your lawyer to put the answer in a written agreement.
In Ontario, the same article says a retention agreement typically covers a retention period, the window during which the employee agrees to stay, often tied to the closing date or a period afterward, and an incentive, commonly a retention bonus whose size and structure are deal-specific. The same Ontario article says there is no standard formula for sizing the incentive and that the agreement should specify consequences, commonly forfeiture of an unpaid or unearned portion. In Ontario, it also says to have any non-solicitation or non-compete drafted together with the retention agreement, deliberately, rather than assuming one document covers everything.
- Ask which managers the business depends on, and whether each is willing to stay after closing
- Ask your lawyer to draft a written retention agreement covering role, compensation and the period of commitment
- Ask each lender what it wants to see about the management plan before it commits
- Ask the seller to describe in writing what each manager does day to day
Replacing the management team
In Ontario, where a business is sold as a going concern and the buyer hires a seller’s employee within 13 weeks of the sale or the employee’s last day, whichever comes first, the employee’s prior service with the seller counts toward vacation, leaves, notice of termination and severance under the Employment Standards Act, 2000, and severance pay has its own separate qualifying tests. In Ontario, a law-firm article on that rule says continuity applies only to employees the purchaser actually hires, and that at common law a sale can still be treated as ending employment with the seller.
In Ontario, a law-firm article on employment due diligence says that in a share purchase every historical employment liability, known or unknown, comes with the corporation unless the purchase agreement’s representations, warranties and indemnities address it, and that in an asset deal one option is simply not hiring the affected employee. Ask an employment lawyer what notice or severance would be owed if a particular manager is replaced, and who bears it under the purchase agreement.
- Ask an employment lawyer what notice or severance would follow if each manager were replaced
- Ask whether the deal is of shares or assets, since in Ontario the employment liabilities land differently
- Ask what recruiting, onboarding and transition would take, and budget for it as its own project
- Ask your accountant what payroll account steps follow a change of ownership, as the CRA page on selling a business describes
How to decide between the two paths
Ask first whether the current management is a problem the buyer needs to solve, or simply people the buyer has not worked with yet. Ask the seller for written descriptions of each manager’s responsibilities, and speak with the managers before closing if the seller agrees. Then ask your lawyer to compare a written retention agreement with the cost and timeline of replacing each role, and bring both to the lender.
Related reading
10 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Buying
Selling
Legal
Sources
This comparison is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryKey Employee Retention Agreements
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryEmployment Due Diligence Red Flags Before Buying an Ontario Business
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryESA Section 9 and Continuity of Employment on an Ontario Business Sale
- 05Government of Ontario — Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills DevelopmentGovernmentContinuity of employment — Your guide to the Employment Standards Act
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.