Is a non-compete in a shareholder agreement enforceable when a minority shareholder sells out?
It can be, but only if a court finds it reasonable. In Martin v. ConCreate (2013 ONCA 72), a minority owner’s non-compete and non-solicit covenants, given on a sale, failed because their duration had no fixed, outside limit. Check which document holds the clause and whether the shareholder is also an employee.
This page covers Ontario; check the rules where you are. Whether a non-compete binds a minority shareholder who sells depends on where the clause sits, what it says about time, and whether the person also works for the business. A covenant given in connection with a sale of a business is tested less strictly than an employee’s, but it must still be reasonable. In one Court of Appeal for Ontario case, a minority owner succeeded against the non-competition and non-solicitation covenants he gave on a sale.
What Martin v. ConCreate decided
Derek Martin worked at ConCreate for 20 years and, through his holding company, acquired a minority interest in it and a related business. When the main owner sold, Martin signed agreements with non-competition and non-solicitation covenants in conjunction with the sale, and kept an indirect interest through limited partnership units. Martin did not challenge the finding that the covenants were not entered into in an employment context, and the Court of Appeal for Ontario noted that a less rigorous test applies to covenants given in connection with the sale of a business. It still held the covenants unreasonable: they ran until a set period after he disposed of that interest, which depended on third-party consents, so there was no fixed, outside limit. The respondents did not contest the lower judge’s finding that, if unreasonable, the covenants could not be saved by severance.
Which document holds the covenant
Martin was not a shareholder agreement case. His covenants were in agreements signed on the sale, and the court said the analysis for a limited partnership agreement differs from that for a unanimous shareholders’ agreement. So ask whether your clause is in the shareholder agreement, the share purchase agreement or a separate document. The court was also troubled that Martin’s period was not calculated from the time of the sale, though it called that factor not determinative. Ask what starts the clock: closing, departure or something else. Our page on enforceability in Canada covers the general test.
Is the shareholder also an employee?
Under Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000, s.67.2(1), no employer shall enter into an employment contract or other agreement with an employee that is, or includes, a non-compete agreement, and a clause made in breach is void (s.67.2(2)). Two exceptions are relevant. One is a sale of a business or part of a business where, as part of the sale, the purchaser and seller agree the seller will not compete and, immediately following the sale, the seller becomes the purchaser’s employee (s.67.2(3)). The other is an employee who is an executive (s.67.2(4)), such as a president or chief executive officer, as the Ontario government’s guide describes. That guide describes the sale exception as applying to a business operated as a sole proprietorship or a partnership, and says the Act does not prohibit non-compete agreements entered into before October 25, 2021. If the minority shareholder also holds a job, ask whether either exception applies; our page on the ban in a sale goes further.
Related reading
6 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Legal
Selling
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Court of Appeal for OntarioCourt decisionMartin v. ConCreate USL Limited Partnership, 2013 ONCA 72
- 02Government of OntarioGovernmentEmployment Standards Act, 2000, S.O. 2000, c. 41
- 03Government of Ontario — Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills DevelopmentGovernmentNon-compete agreements — Your guide to the Employment Standards Act
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.