What happens if a section 167 GST/HST election is missed or invalid?
The relief in subsection 167(1.1) of the Excise Tax Act is written to apply where a joint election is made and, if the recipient is a registrant, filed by the Act’s date. If it is not, GST/HST may be payable on taxable supplies in the sale. Ask an accountant how it applies to the assets sold.
A missed or invalid election does not make the GST/HST on a business sale go away. Subsection 167(1.1) of the Excise Tax Act, which says no tax is payable on most supplies under the agreement, is written to apply where a supplier and a recipient make a joint election and, if the recipient is a registrant, file it with the Minister by the date the Act sets. If those conditions are not met, that relief is not what the Act gives you, and the ordinary rules on taxable supplies are the ones to ask about.
What can make an election fail
Section 167 sets several tests. The sale must be a supply of a business or part of one, and the recipient must acquire all or substantially all of the property that can reasonably be regarded as necessary to carry it on as a business. The joint election is not available where the supplier is a registrant and the recipient is not. The CRA adds that it cannot be made if you sell only one or more assets. The election must also be in prescribed form with prescribed information. The qualifying tests are covered separately.
The seller’s side
Section 221(1) says every person who makes a taxable supply must, as agent of the Crown, collect the tax payable by the recipient. Section 165(1) makes the recipient of a taxable supply the person who pays it, subject to the rest of that Part. So if the election fails and the sale includes taxable supplies, the seller may have been required, subject to the exceptions in section 221, to collect tax that nobody collected at closing. Which supplies are taxable depends on what was sold. The sources read for this page do not cover interest or penalties on uncollected tax, so ask the CRA or an accountant.
The buyer’s side
Section 169(1) allows an input tax credit, to the extent the property or service is acquired for use in commercial activities, to a person who acquires it where, during a reporting period in which the person is a registrant, tax becomes payable or is paid, subject to the rest of that Part. Subsection 169(4) says a registrant may not claim the credit unless, before filing the return, it has obtained sufficient evidence, in a form and with information that lets the amount be determined, and subsection 169(4) adds a further condition where the registrant must itself report the tax on the supply in a return. A buyer that is a registrant should ask its accountant whether a credit is open to it and what documents the claim would need.
Questions to settle before closing
- Did both sides complete the form, and who is filing it?
- Does the sale meet the tests above, or is it only some assets?
- Does the agreement say who bears the tax if the election turns out not to apply?
- Is a later filing day open? The Act lets the Minister determine one on application, so ask the CRA how.
Related reading
6 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Tax
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Government of Canada (Department of Justice)GovernmentExcise Tax Act, section 167 (supply of assets of business)
- 02Government of Canada (Department of Justice)GovernmentExcise Tax Act, section 165 (Imposition of goods and services tax)
- 03Government of Canada (Department of Justice)GovernmentExcise Tax Act, section 221 (Collection of tax)
- 04Government of Canada (Department of Justice)GovernmentExcise Tax Act, section 169 (Input tax credits)
- 05Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 06Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentGST44 — GST/HST Election Concerning the Acquisition of a Business
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.