What is an earn-in and how is it different from an earn-out?
In Ontario, an earn-in is an arrangement where a person acquires equity in a business gradually, in exchange for meeting specified conditions over a defined period. An earn-out ties the amount of sale proceeds to later results, so the earn-in concerns ownership and the earn-out concerns the price.
Ask each side to say in writing which term it means, because the two are different arrangements. This page sets out what the cited sources say about each and what to ask your lawyer about the agreement.
An earn-in builds ownership in stages
In Ontario, one law-firm article defines an earn-in as an arrangement where a person acquires equity in a business gradually, in exchange for meeting specified conditions over a defined period, commonly continued employment or service, hitting performance or revenue targets, or making staged capital contributions. The same Ontario article says that instead of one transaction transferring full ownership on day one, ownership builds up, or vests, as the person delivers on what the agreement requires.
An Ontario article on gradual buy-ins to a partnership says the agreement should set out the total ownership percentage being sold and the schedule for each tranche, for example an initial minority stake now and additional increments at defined future dates. The same Ontario article says later tranches are often funded, at least in part, from the incoming partner’s own share of the partnership’s profits.
An earn-out is about the sale proceeds
CRA’s archived bulletin on shares sold subject to an earnout agreement describes an earnout clause as one where the amount of the proceeds of disposition is determined by reference to future earnings generated by the underlying assets of the corporation. The same bulletin says that, for its purposes, an agreement that merely determines when amounts are paid, rather than the amount of the proceeds, is not an earnout agreement. Ask your lawyer and accountant whether the clause in your agreement fits that description, since the bulletin is archived and speaks of a sale of shares.
BDC lists an earn-out among the ways a seller can remain involved with a company after the sale. Ask who would control the business while the earn-out is running, and ask what the agreement says about how the results are measured.
What to ask about which one is on the table
- Who owns the business at each stage, and who makes decisions in the meantime?
- Is anything being paid now, and what is deferred: ownership, money, or both?
- What happens if the person leaves or the arrangement ends early?
- Which written agreement records the arrangement, and does it sit alongside a shareholders agreement?
What an earn-in agreement needs to address
In Ontario, one law-firm article lists points an earn-in needs to address in writing, and the last item below comes from an Ontario article on gradual buy-ins to a partnership. Ask whether your agreement covers each of them:
- What happens if the person leaves, is terminated or the relationship breaks down before the earn-in completes
- How the business is valued if a buyout or exit happens partway through
- Whether the incoming owner has any voting rights or say in decisions before full ownership vests
- How disputes over whether a milestone was met get resolved
- How each tranche is priced, and what happens if a later tranche does not close
Related reading
14 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Selling
- Expert answerHow does an earn-out provision work in a business sale?
- Expert answerWhat is the difference between an earn-out, a holdback and a vendor note?
- Expert answerWhen is an earn-out the right answer to a price gap?
- Expert answerWhy is a longer earn-out period riskier?
- Expert answerHow are disputes over a contested earn-out payment resolved?
- Expert answerWhat happens in an earn-out dispute over underperformance?
- Expert answerCan a partner buyout be paid based on the business’s future performance?
- Expert answerHow does an earn-out-style partner buyout work?
Financing
Sources
This answer is checked against primary sources. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Treadstone LawLegal commentaryWhat Is an Earn-In in an Ontario Business?
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryStructuring an Earn-In Agreement in Ontario
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryGradual Partnership Buy-Ins in Ontario
- 04Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 05Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentARCHIVED - Shares Sold Subject to an Earnout Agreement
- 06Business Development Bank of CanadaIndustryHow to sell your business
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.