What a diligence finding actually does to a deal
In an Ontario business sale, a buyer can push back on scheduled items by asking for a price adjustment, a specific indemnity, a holdback, or a closing condition tied to resolving the issue. Ask your lawyer whether the finding is already disclosed and which of these fits it.
In Ontario, a buyer who turns up a problem in due diligence has several tools in the purchase agreement. This guide sets out what Ontario sources say about those tools: disclosure schedules, price adjustments, indemnities with baskets and caps, holdbacks and escrow, survival periods, closing conditions and material adverse change clauses. It lists questions for your lawyer rather than saying which tool suits a given finding.
First ask whether the finding is already disclosed
In Ontario, a disclosure schedule is an attachment to a share purchase agreement or asset purchase agreement that lists specific facts, exceptions and qualifications to the representations and warranties the seller makes in the body of the agreement. In Ontario, a representation might read that there is no material litigation involving the business, except as disclosed in a schedule. In Ontario, if a lawsuit is properly listed in that schedule, the representation is still true, and the buyer bought the business knowing about it. In Ontario, if a lawsuit existed and was not listed, the representation is false, and that gap can become the basis of a post-closing indemnity claim.
- Ask your lawyer whether the finding appears in the disclosure schedule, and under which representation.
- Ask the seller’s lawyer for the draft schedule early, and compare it with your diligence list.
- Ask whether the seller can update the schedule between signing and closing, and how an update affects your obligation to close or your right to walk away. In Ontario, that depends entirely on how the mechanism is drafted.
The responses available to a buyer
In Ontario, one article says a buyer can push back on scheduled items during negotiation by asking for a price adjustment, a specific indemnity, a holdback, or a closing condition tied to resolving a disclosed issue before the deal completes. Which one fits a finding is a question for your lawyer and accountant, and the sections below set out what Ontario sources say about each.
Indemnities: baskets and caps
In Ontario, an article describes the basket as a floor and the cap as a ceiling on an indemnity claim: a claim has to clear the basket and stay within the cap to be fully recovered. In Ontario, it says a loss that does not clear the negotiated threshold generally does not count toward a claim at all, unless it falls into a carve-out that bypasses the basket, such as fraud or a specifically negotiated known issue. In Ontario, it says general business representations, fundamental representations and tax representations are commonly subject to different caps.
In Ontario, the article says anything beyond the applicable cap is, absent a carve-out, generally the buyer’s own risk to absorb, and that a court may refuse to enforce a cap in a case of fraud even where no carve-out was negotiated.
- Ask your lawyer whether, if a real problem surfaced in the category you are most worried about, the basket and cap would produce a meaningful recovery.
- Ask whether the cap treats the representations you care most about, such as ownership, a specific known risk or tax, differently from routine operational matters.
- Ask which cap applies if a loss touches more than one category of representation. In Ontario, that depends on how the agreement is drafted.
Holdbacks and escrow
In Ontario, the same article says recovery is pursued from the holdback or escrow first, if one exists, before the seller is chased directly for any remaining amount within the cap. In Ontario, it says drawing on a holdback generally counts against the cap, because the holdback is typically a funding mechanism for claims within the cap rather than a separate pool. In Ontario, another article says purchase agreements frequently line up the release of a holdback with the relevant survival period.
- Ask your lawyer how much would be held back, where it would be held, and when it would be released.
- Ask whether the holdback is tied to a specific finding or to claims generally.
Survival periods
In Ontario, a survival clause sets the deadline for indemnity claims after an Ontario business sale closes. In Ontario, once the survival period for a category has run out, a claim based on breach of that category’s representations is generally barred, even if new facts come to light afterward. In Ontario, the article adds that this depends on how the clause is drafted, and that it does not necessarily eliminate every remedy outside the contract, since a genuinely fraudulent misrepresentation is often treated differently by a court.
In Ontario, the article says most agreements require written notice of a claim within the survival period, even if the exact dollar amount is not fully worked out, and that missing a notice deadline can be as fatal to a claim as missing the survival period itself. Ask your lawyer to calendar each category’s deadline and the notice requirements.
Closing conditions and material adverse change
In Ontario, a condition precedent is an event or requirement that must occur, or be waived, before a party is obligated to close. In Ontario, common conditions include one that the buyer’s review of financials, contracts, employee records and other materials turns up nothing that materially changes the deal, a financing condition, landlord consent to a lease assignment, third-party and regulatory consents, shareholder or director approval, representations remaining true at closing, no material adverse change, and occasionally key employees agreeing to stay on.
In Ontario, if a condition benefiting one party has not been satisfied or waived by the outside date, the usual consequences include that the party benefiting can terminate the agreement without being in breach. In Ontario, the article says the parties may instead agree to extend the outside date or negotiate a waiver, often paired with a price adjustment or added protection for whichever side is giving something up, and that deposit or exclusivity provisions may also be triggered, depending on how the agreement allocates the consequences.
In Ontario, one article says relying on a material adverse change (MAC) clause to walk away from a signed deal is a high bar: the party invoking it generally needs clear, well-supported evidence of a genuine, durable deterioration, not just a bad quarter. In Ontario, it says a MAC clause is not meant to protect a buyer from ordinary business risk, market conditions the buyer already knew about, or simple buyer’s remorse about the price, and that it can still give a buyer leverage to renegotiate if something has genuinely gone wrong.
Questions to take to your lawyer
- Ask your lawyer which response suits each finding, and why: a price adjustment, a specific indemnity, a holdback, a closing condition or stopping the deal.
- Ask which findings you should raise before signing, and which would be handled by a representation in the agreement.
- Ask your accountant to put in writing any amount in a finding that you intend to raise with the seller.
- Ask your lawyer to list every closing condition, who each one benefits, and the outside date.
Related reading
15 pages on the same subject, grouped by topic.
Due diligence
- Expert answerWhat does a genuine red flag in due diligence look like?
- Expert answerWhat do I do if I find a problem during due diligence?
- GuideThe complete due diligence guide for Canadian buyers
- ComparisonDue diligence vs warranty protection
- ChecklistDeal red flags checklist
- Expert answerWhat if the equipment turns out to be worn out?
Legal
Buying
Sources
Every requirement and figure referenced in this guide traces to a primary source. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Treadstone LawLegal commentaryIndemnity Baskets and Caps in an Ontario Business Sale
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryMaterial Adverse Change Clauses in Ontario Business Sale Agreements
- 03Treadstone LawLegal commentaryDisclosure Schedules in an Ontario Business Sale Agreement
- 04Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Long Do Representations and Warranties Survive After an Ontario Business Sale?
- 05Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 06Treadstone LawLegal commentaryConditions Precedent to Closing in an Ontario Business Sale Agreement
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.