What is a trades business worth?
What a trades business is worth depends on how it is valued: BDC says a valuator chooses an earnings-based, market-based or asset-based method, or a combination of them. Ask how any number was reached, what was added back to earnings, and what it assumes about the owner, contracts, equipment and licences.
BDC describes three families of valuation method that a business valuator can choose from: earnings-based, market-based and asset-based. This guide does not give a number for any trades business. It explains what each method looks at and, for a trades business, which questions and documents decide whether a number can be relied on.
The three methods BDC describes
BDC says earnings-based methods determine the valuation from past results and forecast cash flow or earnings, and are commonly used for businesses that generate reasonable profits and whose value is greater than that of their net assets alone. Market-based methods calculate the valuation from a multiple of a metric such as earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, and BDC says the multiple and type of ratio vary greatly with the industry, market conditions and other factors. Asset-based methods determine the value of assets minus liabilities and, BDC says, are typically used for businesses whose value is asset-related rather than operations-related.
BDC also notes that a company’s fair market value is not necessarily the price it will sell for, and that the final selling price can be affected by factors such as market conditions, the buyer’s strategic interests, due diligence, availability of financing, the seller’s eagerness to sell and the seller’s involvement after the transaction. It says a valuator typically reviews records including financial statements, the prior-year tax return, discretionary and non-recurring expenses, management compensation and a list of employees, and that valuation reports range from basic to highly detailed, with greater cost and assurance as they become more thorough.
Rule-of-thumb multiples: what to ask
An Ontario legal guide on valuing a business before listing advises caution about any rule-of-thumb multiple offered without underlying analysis, saying valuation is deal- and industry-specific and a generic multiple applied to revenue or profit is not a substitute for a proper valuation. Another Ontario guide says reliable comparable data is harder to find for small private businesses than for public companies or real estate, which limits how much weight the market-based approach can carry on its own for many small Ontario deals. If someone quotes you a multiple for a trades business, ask which earnings figure it applies to, which year, and what sales it is drawn from.
Earnings: ask how the figure was normalized
If a seller’s discretionary earnings figure is quoted for a trades business, ask exactly how it was calculated. An Ontario guide on valuation basics for buyers says an earnings-based approach often starts from a normalized earnings figure that adds back one-time expenses, the owner’s personal expenses run through the business, and above- or below-market owner compensation. The same guide says these approaches depend heavily on how conservatively or optimistically the adjustments are made, that this is a common area where seller and buyer disagree, and that scrutinizing each add-back individually is one of the highest-value things a buyer’s accountant can do.
For a trades business, ask for support for each add-back that appears on the list:
- A family member’s salary: what work is done, and the pay records
- A personal vehicle or equipment run through the company: the invoices and the business-use records
- Tools or equipment bought for a single job: the invoice and the job it relates to
- Cash payments to casual labour: how they were recorded and reported
- Revenue: job-costing or invoicing records reconciled to bank deposits and to the tax return
Backlog, work in progress and contracts
Ask for a schedule of signed contracts, the current job backlog and any recurring service or maintenance agreements, showing the term, the renewal terms and who the customer is. Ask for a job-by-job work-in-progress schedule showing what has been invoiced, what has been collected, what work remains and what materials have already been bought, so that the same job is not counted twice. Ask whether any key customer contract contains a change-of-control or anti-assignment clause, and whether the customer could end the contract on a change of ownership.
Owner dependence and customer concentration
Ask who estimates jobs, who runs the crews and who holds the relationships with customers and general contractors. Ask whether pricing and quoting are written down or live only with the owner, and whether the owner would stay on for a transition period after closing. Ask also how much revenue comes from one or two customers, how long each of those relationships has run, its renewal history and who else at the business deals with that customer.
Equipment, vehicles and licences
Ask whether the vehicles and equipment are included in the earnings-based number or valued separately, and who inspected them. Ask for the maintenance records for each major vehicle and piece of equipment, and ask your lawyer which searches to run for security interests registered against them. For each licence or permit, ask the body that issues it whether it is held by a person or by the corporation, and whether a buyer would need to apply fresh.
Tax on the sale
An Ontario valuation guide notes that asset and share deals carry different tax consequences and liability exposure for buyer and seller. The CRA’s page on selling a business covers the business number, the payroll account and GST/HST, and says that if you are selling you may be able to jointly elect with the purchaser, using Form GST44, to have no GST/HST payable on the sale if the conditions it sets out are met, including that you are selling the business you established or carried on. Work through the structure with an accountant and a qualified valuator before any number is finalized.
Related reading
6 pages on the same subject.
Sources
Every requirement and figure referenced in this guide traces to a primary source. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Much Is a Small Business Worth? Valuation Basics for Ontario Buyers
- 02Treadstone LawLegal commentaryGetting a Business Valuation Before You List
- 03Business Development Bank of CanadaIndustryHow to sell your business
- 04Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 05Treadstone AssociatesAdvisorySmall & Mid-Sized Businesses
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.