How to determine the value of a business in Canada
To determine the value of a business in Canada, choose among earnings-based, market-based and asset-based approaches (BDC notes a valuator may use one or more) and check how reported earnings were adjusted. The purpose, whether a sale, tax planning, a dispute or financing, then shapes what you should ask for.
Asking what a business is worth can sound like a request for a single number, but valuation in Canada is a process, not a lookup table. It involves choosing an approach, adjusting the financial statements, and deciding who will do the work and why. A broker sizing up a listing, a Chartered Business Valuator preparing a report, and two shareholders working out a buyout are not doing the same exercise, even from identical financial statements. This page is a map of the approaches, the kinds of “valuation” people mean, and how the purpose changes what you should ask for. If you are evaluating a specific business to buy, the search starts one step earlier, in how to find a business worth buying.
The three families of method
The Business Development Bank of Canada (BDC) describes a variety of valuation approaches, grouped as earnings-based, market-based and asset-based, and says a valuator may use one or more of them depending on the available information and the type of business and transaction. Earnings-based approaches review forecasted earnings or cash flow and past results. Market-based approaches apply a valuation multiple, which may be based on EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization), revenue or other metrics. Asset-based approaches, BDC says, are typically used for businesses whose value is asset-related rather than operations-related, and are also applied when a business generates poor returns or is expected to be liquidated. For a side-by-side comparison, see business valuation methods compared.
Ask whether a figure is enterprise value, which BDC describes as a firm’s total value including both its interest-bearing debt and equity components, or only the owners’ share (equity value), and how debt and cash were treated. Reading one as if it were the other is an easy way to talk past each other.
Earnings first, and how they are adjusted
BDC says earnings-based approaches are commonly used for established businesses that generate reasonable returns and whose value is greater than that of their assets alone. In Ontario, an earnings-based valuation often starts from a normalized earnings figure that adds back one-time expenses and the owner’s personal expenses run through the business, and adjusts above- or below-market owner compensation. That is a common area where seller and buyer disagree, because the result depends on how conservatively or optimistically the adjustments are made. Ask for every adjustment as its own line, with the document that supports it, and for the number of years of results behind the figure.
A business with few hard assets is a good example of why to ask. For a service business, ask how much of the work depends on the owner and on a few client relationships, and how the valuator treated that. Some businesses are discussed against a revenue multiple instead of an earnings multiple, as in a B2B e-commerce store. Ask the valuator why the chosen measure suits the business.
When asset values matter
If a business’s value is asset-related rather than operations-related, it generates poor returns, or it is expected to be liquidated, BDC notes that an asset-based approach may be applied. Ask whether the asset figures are at fair market value or at a liquidation value, because those answer different questions, and ask who valued the equipment and how.
If the business owns real estate, ask whether the property is valued separately from the operating business and by whom. See valuing a business that owns its own real estate and business valuation vs. real estate appraisal.
Forecasts and comparable sales
BDC notes that different earnings-based approaches are used depending on whether earnings are expected to be stable in coming years. If a valuator projects several years of cash flow, ask who prepared the forecast, what it assumes (a contract ending, a new location opening), how the rate used to bring future cash flow to today’s dollars was chosen, and how much the result moves when the assumptions change. For comparable sales, ask where the deals come from, when they closed and how they match the business in industry, size and location. Ask whether the multiple can be traced to those deals.
Three different things people call “a valuation”
When someone gives you a number, ask how they arrived at it. It may be one of the three things below, and a figure that suits one purpose may not suit another.
- A rule-of-thumb estimate: in Ontario, a generic industry multiple applied to revenue or profit, which is described as not a substitute for a proper valuation. See rule-of-thumb valuation.
- A broker’s opinion of value, tied to a specific business. Ask whether it is part of a pitch for the listing and what evidence sits behind it.
- A formal report from a Chartered Business Valuator, which BDC suggests hiring to get an objective picture of a company’s value or to judge whether a buyer’s offer is reasonable.
In Ontario, an independent valuation obtained before listing can give a seller a baseline they understand and can defend, and a second opinion can be useful in complex, co-owned or disputed situations. BDC also notes that a valuator’s figure is a guideline for approaching negotiations. A quick multiple-based estimate and a formal appraisal differ in the analysis behind them, so ask which one you are holding. Whether you need the formal report depends on what the number is for; see do I need a professional valuation.
What a formal engagement involves
Ask the valuator for an engagement letter that states the purpose of the valuation and the standard of value applied, and ask what records they will need; BDC says a valuator typically reviews records including financial statements, the prior-year tax return, discretionary and non-recurring expenses, management compensation and a list of employees. Ask for a written report that sets out its assumptions, chosen method and reasoning. How to read a business valuation report covers what to check, whether you commissioned the report or received one from a buyer, lender or estate.
What the valuation is for
The purpose changes what you ask for, so say what the number is for before you commission it.
Selling the business
Ask the valuator which standard of value the report uses and what it means in plain terms. BDC notes that a company’s fair market value is not necessarily the price it will sell for, and a figure for an open-market sale is a different question from what you would like to receive; see valuation gap. The practical answer to what your business is worth starts from normalized earnings. What you would walk away with after deal costs, financing structure and tax is a separate calculation for your accountant.
Tax planning and family transfers
Some transfers involve tax elections or deductions where value matters. For example, under subsection 85(1) of the Income Tax Act a taxpayer and a taxable Canadian corporation can jointly elect (CRA form T2057) on a disposition of eligible property for consideration that includes shares of the corporation, and the amount agreed in the election is limited by reference to the property’s fair market value; the lifetime capital gains deduction can apply to dispositions of qualified small business corporation shares, subject to conditions. Ask your accountant what valuation evidence the transaction needs and who should prepare it. For a family sale, see how to value a business for a family transfer.
A dispute between owners
In Ontario, where partners have no binding valuation mechanism in their agreement, the most common next step is retaining an independent business valuator, ideally one both partners agree to jointly. In Ontario, a buy-in for an incoming partner and a buyout for a departing one can be priced differently, even for the same business. Check what your shareholder or partnership agreement says about valuation before a dispute starts, and ask a lawyer where you are.
Financing the purchase
A lender assesses the purchase on its own terms. Ask the lender how it values the business, whether it focuses on cash flow covering loan payments, how it treats pledged assets and what loan-to-value ratio it applies; see how lenders value a business. Also ask whether it will want a quality-of-earnings report. Treadstone Law, an Ontario firm, says banks and BDC often require one before approving an Ontario business acquisition loan, more likely for cash-flow-based lending on larger or more complex acquisitions than for smaller, asset-based loans, and describes it as an independent analysis, typically by an accounting firm, of whether the target’s earnings are accurate and sustainable; see quality of earnings.
Questions that go beyond the method
BDC notes that the multiple used varies with factors such as the industry and size of the company and market conditions, and in Ontario a generic multiple is described as ignoring what makes a specific business more or less valuable, such as its customer base, its dependence on the owner and its financial trends. Ask the valuator how the report treats owner dependence, customer concentration and the earnings trend. What pushes a multiple up or down works through those factors, and what your business is worth without you in it covers owner dependence on its own. The distance between an asking multiple and what a buyer or lender will support is a question to put to your advisor early.
Special situations that change the process
- Messy or disorganized records: reconstructing a picture from bank statements and tax filings first
- More than one owner: settling price, process and how proceeds split before a buyer appears
- A multi-unit franchise: how management and valuation work across locations
- Franchise versus independent: a comparison of the two
- A business in decline: whether it is ever worth buying
Inventory, equipment and goodwill
A multiple does not settle every line of a deal. Ask how inventory, hard assets and goodwill are handled in the price and in the purchase agreement.
- Inventory: ask how it will be counted and valued, when the count happens, and how a difference from the listed figure is settled
- Retail inventory: ask which stock the store owns outright and which is on consignment or owned by a supplier
- Machinery, trucks and other hard assets: ask whether an independent equipment appraisal exists, and see how a fleet gets valued in a sale
- Goodwill: in Ontario, it is described as the gap between what a business’s tangible assets, less liabilities, are worth on their own and what a buyer is willing to pay for the whole operating business. Ask how much of the price is attributed to it and what supports it.
Industry-specific starting points
Each of these pages sets out what to ask for that kind of business. Treat any rule-of-thumb range as a starting point to test, not a conclusion.
Food and hospitality: a restaurant, a bar and pub, a catering company, a bed and breakfast, a banquet hall and event venue, a brewery or brewpub and a campground or RV park.
Trades and services: an auto repair shop, an HVAC business, a car wash and a cleaning business. Professional practices and retail: a dental practice, a chiropractic clinic, a bookkeeping firm and a convenience store. The library covers more business types beyond these.
Related reading
6 pages on the same subject.
Valuation
Sources
Every requirement and figure referenced in this guide traces to a primary source. Links were last confirmed on the dates shown.
- 01Government of CanadaGovernmentIncome Tax Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. 1 (5th Supp.)
- 02Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernmentWhat is enterprise value?
- 03Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentSelling a business
- 04Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentT2057 Election on Disposition of Property by a Taxpayer to a Taxable Canadian Corporation
- 05Canada Revenue AgencyGovernmentLine 25400 – Capital gains deduction
- 06Business Development Bank of CanadaGovernmentBusiness valuation: What’s your company worth?
- 07Treadstone LawLegal commentaryHow Much Is a Small Business Worth? Valuation Basics for Ontario Buyers
- 08Treadstone LawLegal commentaryGetting a Business Valuation Before You List
- 09Treadstone LawLegal commentaryBusiness Valuator Before Buying a Business in Ontario
- 10Treadstone LawLegal commentaryIs it worth paying for more than one valuation before I list?
- 11Treadstone LawLegal commentaryAsking Price vs. Fair Value in Ontario Business Sales
- 12Treadstone LawLegal commentaryPartner Buyout Valuation Disputes — Ontario
- 13Treadstone LawLegal commentaryBuy-In vs Buyout Valuation in Ontario
- 14Treadstone LawLegal commentaryQuality of Earnings Reports in Acquisition Lending
- 15Treadstone LawLegal commentaryEvaluating Goodwill When Buying a Business
- 16Business Development Bank of CanadaIndustryHow to sell your business
- 17Business Development Bank of CanadaIndustryBusiness Purchase or Transfer Loan
- 18Canadian Federation of Independent BusinessResearch dataSuccession Tsunami: Preparing for a decade of small business transitions
- 19CBV InstituteIndustryCBV Expertise
Deavo is an advertising and listings platform, not a brokerage, law firm or valuation firm. This page is general information, not legal, tax, accounting or valuation advice, and rules differ by province. Confirm anything you rely on with a qualified professional before you act on it.